Monday 16th July
Start of a new week ... what lies ahead? Family drama or ArHi romance?
Quick Update
Reality Check for Arnav ... his sister is cuckoo and thinks he would send her red roses. And he would do that because ...? Romantic love is the same as sibling love ...? Urrggghhhh ...
Reality Check for Anjali ... her brother's world does not revolve around her ... surprise, surprise, he loves his wife. And shock and horror ... maybe more than he loves his sister! All because he wanted to celebrate his wife's birthday
Reality Check no. 2 for Arnav ... his wife is not a Sati Savitri Bhartiya Nari ... or even an SP bahu ... sweetly grateful for whatever her hubby does for her on her birthday. She has definite ideas about what she wants, and if you don't measure up, boy, are you in trouble!
SN - And if on top of that, you try to act the Laad Governer with her, you are even deeper in trouble.
Considering all she really wanted was for you to wish her, she wasn't really asking for too much, was she?
Reality Check for Khushi ... of sorts ... ASR and Arnav are the same person, she'd better get used to living with both of them. And ASR has a ton of 'takniki kharabis' ... inability to say a few common phrases like Sorry, Happy Birthday, Please and Thank You among them ... :) Though it seems she is getting on top of things here ..
So Anjali remembers all the SK scenes, Arnav slapping Shyam and throwing him out, and also remembers that Khushi likes red roses ... and actually puts two and two together correctly ... the flowers weren't for her after all!
So all three - Anjali, Khushi and Arnav know who the flowers really were for. In this show of MU's, that is pretty much a first!
Payal and NK were cute ... they both got gifts for Khushi ... and NK promised to be always there for her :) He is such a cute friend!
Arnav ... tut tut, dear boy ... you're supposed to be trying to win Khushi back, remember? And show her that you want her forever and ever ... forcing her to cut her own cake and eat it is not quite the right way of doing that!
Actually I was glad that ASR didn't turn into Arnav completely ... one ME was cute, but today it was good to see the blunt, hopelessly unromantic ASR trying and failing miserably ... and going back to his usual dhamkis ... cut the cake or else! :)) And it was good to see tigress Khushi back ... she's been meek and sacrificing for far too long!
I was very glad that Anjali didn't actually interrupt the ArHi celebration ... umm, cake cutting ... that would have made it unbearable! Good thing she just got her first reality check and went back quietly. Anjali, silly girl, last night you were swaying while heating a glass of milk, and today you're quite okay with making a pot of kheer for your brother?!
Anjali's final words made it clear that she did always put Arnav above Shyam ... and fully expects him to do the same thing. No wonder Shyam started roving ... I actually hate to say this ... I don't like blaming the woman ... but it seems a definite factor.
And I liked the precap ... I want Anjali to see more and more that Arnav has a life beyond his sister ... it's the reality check that she badly needs ... that the world does not revolve around her.
*edited*
Rewatching the episode, the main theme seems to be the reality check for Anjali ... the start of the bursting of her bubble ... not about Shyam, but about Arnav, and her position in his life.
Mostly Indian telly and movies glorify the mother-son bond, often putting it above the husband-wife one ... the Nirupa Roy effect, we call it here on R&R ;)
This story seems to be about the brother-sister bond, and whether it can ever be above the husband-wife bond ... and my take is the same as it was earlier ... all bonds are sacred, parent-child bonds and sibling bonds are blood ties, and hence irreversible ... whether you choose to acknowledge them or not, you can't shake free of them ... they are ties of duty, responsibility and love.
But a husband-wife bond ... a true one ... is a bond made in heaven ...the only bond not forged by blood, but by the heart, you don't choose your family, but your life partner is your choice ... love is the base, and trust, duty, responsibility all follow.
Jeevan saathi, saat janam ka saath ... if you believe in this then a husband-wife bond is actually stronger than all blood ties ... while blood ties last for one lifetime, the bond between spouses is designed for seven lifetimes.
But will Anjali understand this? A person who has had not one, but two disastrous matches ... one never started, and one which broke after three short years?
So going ahead from this ... and into the episode ...
Red roses ... and Arnav reacted exactly the way I expected him to ... and so did Khushi ... Arnav helpless, silent ... 'yes, Di, these are for you ...' because his Di is already teetering emotionally, he did manage to tell her that the flowers were not from her creepwa husband, but that was enough of a letdown for her, to tell her that they are not even for her, would be even worse.
And Khushi understands ... of course she does ... any halfway understanding wife would not have it any other way ... especially as he conveys with his eyes and his words who the roses were really intended for ... 'I know whose favorite flowers these are.'
And Anjali feels a little better, her brother was after all worried for her all along ...
Very sweet Payal-Khushi scene ... Deepali is very good with Sanaya, her scenes with Akshay are the let down. Payal back to being the cute loving, teasing older sister ... loved that 'don't give me that' look on Sanaya's face as Khushi tells Payal to quite kidding, and the eagerness with which Payal waits for Khushi to unwrap her gift, with that personal touch, she put the gota herself ... and the heartfelt wishes ... always, always, always, always remain happy ... :)
NK pulls Khushi for her next surprise ... which Payal also knows about and is so happy for ... :)
NK gives Khushi his gift, with more wishes ... I'll be there for you, whenever you need me ...
And NK forwards Arnav's apology of sorts ... Di got the flowers meant for Khushi, did she feel bad?
Of course she didn't ... it brought a smile to Di's face ...
Arnav knew she would feel this way ... :">
And NK pushes Khushi into her room ... and shuts the door ...
He should have locked it and thrown away the key :) :-<
Khushi enters the dark room ... and sees her birthday surprise ... and is delighted and touched ... the lights, the decorations, the cake ...
and a very unsure, awkward husband ... who's not quite sure how to go about things now ... this is all completely new to him ...
So she waits expectantly ... and he hesitates ... nope, no clue what to do next ...
The bag is a great excuse ... something he can scold her for ... now that he knows how to do ... :)) Khushi merrily explains she washed it, but that made things worse ... why are expensive things always so fragile?!
Bag was bad topic choice ... he's getting angry and he doesn't want to get angry today ... so end of discussion ...
Khushi waits expectantly again ... again the guy is tongue-tied ...
'You liked the lights at New Years ... so I did these for you ...'
And Khushi is getting a teensy weensy bit impatient ... just how hard is it to wish someone anyway? She tries to help, but with a slight snap in her tone ... 'do you want to say something to me?'
And this was a reminder of the Sorry scene ... where she knew what he wanted to say, but had to poke and push him into saying the word, by laying bare all her own deepest vulnerabilities ...
Umm, err ... yes, he does ... what he meant to say was ... 'It's your birthday ... so ...'
'Yes, it's my birthday ... so what?!'
So happy birthday, darling, and many happy returns of the day now let's cut your cake ... I got it for you with so much love ... Nope, not happening ...
'So ... err, yes ... so ... cut the cake ...'
He's on surer ground now ... 'Yep ... cut the cake ... that's it ...' simple ... he's done it.
She doesn't think so. Arms crossed, angry young woman.
'Why?!'
He's flummoxed ... he said it, didn't he ... just cut the cake now. But Khushi is not impressed ... she wants the words, the wishes ... he's been trying the whole damn day, what with Happy Singh, hands free, haal chaal ... and he can't say two simple words which are all she wants ... she won't let him get away this easy!
When I got married, there was a tussle with my hubby, I wanted him to wish me at midnight because that was the way all my friends had done it for the last ten years ... my hubby was damned if he would do what my friends did, he wanted to be different ... and unique ... so the gifts and cake were brought the next day ... but I wasn't happy, because he hadn't been the first to wish me at midnight - the way I wanted it. So did I understand Khushi? Oh boy, yes :) ... how hard is it just to say the words? On my birthday, you do what I want ... on your birthday, I will do what you like. :)
Besides, Khushi has never been one to put up with her LG's idiosyncracies ... she made him say Sorry ... and she will make him say Happy Birthday ...
But her LG is no less ... he lights the candle ... 'come on ... let's cut the cake ...'
The candle goes out ... and LG starts to lose it ... 'hurry up, and cut the cake ... it's windy ...'
And Khushi starts to lose it too ... 'I'm not cutting any cakes ...' so there ... not till you say it ...
Arnav gets more and more angry ... 'at least blow the candle ...'
'Nope, I won't ...'
'It's your birthday, Khushi!'
Yes, he got the point ... 'it's my birthday, so I will do what I like ... I won't blow the candle, or cut the cake or eat it ... and don't you force me ...'
And he's lost it now ... temper flaring ... ah, back to their normal fights, now this he can handle ... the fiery fighting Khushi ... 'do as I say and cut the cake now ... this is the last time I'm doing this ...'
It was interesting to see how they were both so tongue-tied when it was time for soft words and romance ... and completely comfortable when back to fighting mode ...but the big difference - this time the fight was completely with Sadda Haq ... 'do as I say ..'. 'no, I won't, you have to do what I want first ...'
And Anjali approaches closer and closer with a bucket of kheer for her Chotey, he got her flowers earlier, so she reciprocates by making his favorite kheer, secure in her little bubble that her brother is completely worried about her and spending his entire day and night thinking of how to make her life easier and happier ... so what if her husband has gone, her brother is there, he will right her world again for her ... like he always does ...
While Arnav is trying his best to control his own temper and his equally tempestuous wife ... who, far from being grateful for all his efforts, is harping on the little fact that he didn't wish her ... he makes the mistake of handing her the knife and commanding her to cut the cake ... and Khushi warns him, 'don't give me that knife, I'm not responsible for what I do with it...' :))
(Have to say, I loved them here ... Sanaya's expression with the knife was hilarious!)
And Arnav reverts back to ASR and makes her cut the cake, holding her very, very close all the while ... and picks up a piece to feed her ... much to her fury ...
Just in time for Anjali to enter the room, without knocking she pushes her married brother's door open ... umm, she deserves what she gets in my opinion, just for that ... although I will add that she has been trying to block out Khushi's very existence in the house from her mind as far as possible, helped by everyone else avoiding the topic as well ... so for her, Khushi doesn't exist ...
Till she sees Arnav-Khushi very much together ... celebrating Khushi's birthday next to a beautifully decorated pool, with cake ... all that her brother has done for his wife ... while his sister's world is collapsing, and he should be only worried about his sister ...
Reality check for Anjali ... her first one ...
Even as Arnav Khushi share a small sensuous moment, as he wipes off the cake from her lip ... and tempers cool slowly ... Khushi's slower to cool than Arnav's, he is happy, he got what he wanted ... but she continues to fume and mutter soundlessly to herself ...
'What are you saying ...?!'
'I'm promising myself ... everything I will do for you on your birthday ... stuff you full of things you don't want ... turn off your AC and light the coil you're allergic to, so you can't talk ... and ... is there anything else I can do to irritate the heck out of you?'
And Arnav just grins slightly ... vintage Khushi! Besides, she just said she'd be very much there for his birthday ... :) :">
And Anjali limps back heartbroken to her room ... and her mind starts to unfreeze slowly ...
Arnav promising Anjali he would always be there for her ... his entire world is her, his Di ...
Khushi feeding Shyam kheer, leaving silently with him to unknown destination ...
Mami saying Khushi asked Shyam to divorce Anjali ...
Khushi did it all to trap Shyam ...
Arnav threw Shyam out for misbehaving with his wife ...
And we get a glimpse of how Anjali's mind has started working ... she was the most important person in her brother's life ... Khushi trapped Shyam and had him thrown out ... and Arnav threw out Shyam because he misbehaved with Khushi ...
When did Khushi take over Anjali's place in Arnav's life? Anjali was ready to magnanimously give her that place ... as long as Khushi remained suitably grateful for the honour ... when did it happen that that place was no longer Anjali's to give away?
More than Didi ki Saut ... this is about Biwi ki Saut Didi ...
The rest of the ArHi fight was actually more a filler ... to keep them apart so that they don't reach the big C yet ... :)) And to bring home to Arnav that sometimes words do matter, more than actions ...
His ILU made all the difference to Khushi, gave her the courage and the confidence to go hunt for him.
His saying HBD, something he never says to anyone else, not even to his Di, would have made her feel she was special for him ... might give her the confidence to stay the course all through the rocky road ahead with his Di ... instead of wanting to bow out of his life ...
And Anjali's thought processes start working slowly ... the flowers were for Khushi, not for her ...
She, Anjali, was Arnav's life, his world ... her world has shattered, her heart has broken, and he has forgotten about it already? He's too busy romancing his wife? Does celebrating his wife's birthday takes precedence over comforting his sister who is so shattered?
Is Khushi more important to him than she, Anjali, is?!
Anjali, this was just the first one ... many more reality checks are in store for you ... before you finally start blaming the right person ...
Thoughts:
I don't blame Anjali for feeling shattered and lost. Her world has collapsed around her ans she's still trying to pick up the pieces. She thought she was the center of her husband's world ... she is not. She comforted herself with the thought that so what if her husband left, her brother is still her rock, he will do anything for her, because his world revolves around her. And the whole family, in their effort to give her time to come to terms with the situation, unknowingly perpetuates it, by not mentioning Khushi at all, by not allowing Khushi to go near her ... so that Anjali can convince herself that Khushi is out of their lives as well, she doesn't exist ...
Besides, she asked her brother to throw Khushi out ... throw out the person who caused this entire mess ... and her brother always does what she asks ...
He made a booboo this morning, but he was properly sorry about it ... he disappeared the entire day ... he was obviously feeling so bad that he spent the day thinking about how to make it up to her ... he brought her those beautiful flowers, her favorite ... yes, her brother loves her, he will do anything for her ... because she is his world ...
Except that Reality Bites ... Di is not his world ... the flowers were not for her, they were for Khushi, whose favorite flowers they also are ...
He didn't spend the entire day in remorse that he hurt his Di ... he spent it in planning a birthday surprise for his wife ...
He is not lost and shattered because his Di's world ... he is more occupied in wooing his wife, because of whom that world shattered ...
Anjali has lost her place in her husband's life ... because Khushi trapped him ...
She has lost her place in her brother's life because he is in love with Khushi ...
I can foresee Anjali turning several shades darker :)
And the good thing is, that every time she hurts Khushi, or tries to, Arnav will be more hurt, and will do even more to make up to Khushi :)
I do feel sorry for Arnav in all this ... he has a tough time ahead between psychotic imbalanced, insecure sister, and annoyed, recalcitrant and not very secure wife. Because Khushi is not yet completely secure in her husband's love and her place in his life either ... though she's getting there ... she's learning to demand her due. And with a SIL like Anjali, she needs to do that.
Start of a new week ... what lies ahead? Family drama or ArHi romance?
Quick Update
Reality Check for Arnav ... his sister is cuckoo and thinks he would send her red roses. And he would do that because ...? Romantic love is the same as sibling love ...? Urrggghhhh ...
Reality Check for Anjali ... her brother's world does not revolve around her ... surprise, surprise, he loves his wife. And shock and horror ... maybe more than he loves his sister! All because he wanted to celebrate his wife's birthday
Reality Check no. 2 for Arnav ... his wife is not a Sati Savitri Bhartiya Nari ... or even an SP bahu ... sweetly grateful for whatever her hubby does for her on her birthday. She has definite ideas about what she wants, and if you don't measure up, boy, are you in trouble!
SN - And if on top of that, you try to act the Laad Governer with her, you are even deeper in trouble.
Considering all she really wanted was for you to wish her, she wasn't really asking for too much, was she?
Reality Check for Khushi ... of sorts ... ASR and Arnav are the same person, she'd better get used to living with both of them. And ASR has a ton of 'takniki kharabis' ... inability to say a few common phrases like Sorry, Happy Birthday, Please and Thank You among them ... :) Though it seems she is getting on top of things here ..
So Anjali remembers all the SK scenes, Arnav slapping Shyam and throwing him out, and also remembers that Khushi likes red roses ... and actually puts two and two together correctly ... the flowers weren't for her after all!
So all three - Anjali, Khushi and Arnav know who the flowers really were for. In this show of MU's, that is pretty much a first!
Payal and NK were cute ... they both got gifts for Khushi ... and NK promised to be always there for her :) He is such a cute friend!
Arnav ... tut tut, dear boy ... you're supposed to be trying to win Khushi back, remember? And show her that you want her forever and ever ... forcing her to cut her own cake and eat it is not quite the right way of doing that!
Actually I was glad that ASR didn't turn into Arnav completely ... one ME was cute, but today it was good to see the blunt, hopelessly unromantic ASR trying and failing miserably ... and going back to his usual dhamkis ... cut the cake or else! :)) And it was good to see tigress Khushi back ... she's been meek and sacrificing for far too long!
I was very glad that Anjali didn't actually interrupt the ArHi celebration ... umm, cake cutting ... that would have made it unbearable! Good thing she just got her first reality check and went back quietly. Anjali, silly girl, last night you were swaying while heating a glass of milk, and today you're quite okay with making a pot of kheer for your brother?!
Anjali's final words made it clear that she did always put Arnav above Shyam ... and fully expects him to do the same thing. No wonder Shyam started roving ... I actually hate to say this ... I don't like blaming the woman ... but it seems a definite factor.
And I liked the precap ... I want Anjali to see more and more that Arnav has a life beyond his sister ... it's the reality check that she badly needs ... that the world does not revolve around her.
*edited*
Rewatching the episode, the main theme seems to be the reality check for Anjali ... the start of the bursting of her bubble ... not about Shyam, but about Arnav, and her position in his life.
Mostly Indian telly and movies glorify the mother-son bond, often putting it above the husband-wife one ... the Nirupa Roy effect, we call it here on R&R ;)
This story seems to be about the brother-sister bond, and whether it can ever be above the husband-wife bond ... and my take is the same as it was earlier ... all bonds are sacred, parent-child bonds and sibling bonds are blood ties, and hence irreversible ... whether you choose to acknowledge them or not, you can't shake free of them ... they are ties of duty, responsibility and love.
But a husband-wife bond ... a true one ... is a bond made in heaven ...the only bond not forged by blood, but by the heart, you don't choose your family, but your life partner is your choice ... love is the base, and trust, duty, responsibility all follow.
Jeevan saathi, saat janam ka saath ... if you believe in this then a husband-wife bond is actually stronger than all blood ties ... while blood ties last for one lifetime, the bond between spouses is designed for seven lifetimes.
But will Anjali understand this? A person who has had not one, but two disastrous matches ... one never started, and one which broke after three short years?
So going ahead from this ... and into the episode ...
Red roses ... and Arnav reacted exactly the way I expected him to ... and so did Khushi ... Arnav helpless, silent ... 'yes, Di, these are for you ...' because his Di is already teetering emotionally, he did manage to tell her that the flowers were not from her creepwa husband, but that was enough of a letdown for her, to tell her that they are not even for her, would be even worse.
And Khushi understands ... of course she does ... any halfway understanding wife would not have it any other way ... especially as he conveys with his eyes and his words who the roses were really intended for ... 'I know whose favorite flowers these are.'
And Anjali feels a little better, her brother was after all worried for her all along ...
Very sweet Payal-Khushi scene ... Deepali is very good with Sanaya, her scenes with Akshay are the let down. Payal back to being the cute loving, teasing older sister ... loved that 'don't give me that' look on Sanaya's face as Khushi tells Payal to quite kidding, and the eagerness with which Payal waits for Khushi to unwrap her gift, with that personal touch, she put the gota herself ... and the heartfelt wishes ... always, always, always, always remain happy ... :)
NK pulls Khushi for her next surprise ... which Payal also knows about and is so happy for ... :)
NK gives Khushi his gift, with more wishes ... I'll be there for you, whenever you need me ...
And NK forwards Arnav's apology of sorts ... Di got the flowers meant for Khushi, did she feel bad?
Of course she didn't ... it brought a smile to Di's face ...
Arnav knew she would feel this way ... :">
And NK pushes Khushi into her room ... and shuts the door ...
He should have locked it and thrown away the key :) :-<
Khushi enters the dark room ... and sees her birthday surprise ... and is delighted and touched ... the lights, the decorations, the cake ...
and a very unsure, awkward husband ... who's not quite sure how to go about things now ... this is all completely new to him ...
So she waits expectantly ... and he hesitates ... nope, no clue what to do next ...
The bag is a great excuse ... something he can scold her for ... now that he knows how to do ... :)) Khushi merrily explains she washed it, but that made things worse ... why are expensive things always so fragile?!
Bag was bad topic choice ... he's getting angry and he doesn't want to get angry today ... so end of discussion ...
Khushi waits expectantly again ... again the guy is tongue-tied ...
'You liked the lights at New Years ... so I did these for you ...'
And Khushi is getting a teensy weensy bit impatient ... just how hard is it to wish someone anyway? She tries to help, but with a slight snap in her tone ... 'do you want to say something to me?'
And this was a reminder of the Sorry scene ... where she knew what he wanted to say, but had to poke and push him into saying the word, by laying bare all her own deepest vulnerabilities ...
Umm, err ... yes, he does ... what he meant to say was ... 'It's your birthday ... so ...'
'Yes, it's my birthday ... so what?!'
So happy birthday, darling, and many happy returns of the day now let's cut your cake ... I got it for you with so much love ... Nope, not happening ...
'So ... err, yes ... so ... cut the cake ...'
He's on surer ground now ... 'Yep ... cut the cake ... that's it ...' simple ... he's done it.
She doesn't think so. Arms crossed, angry young woman.
'Why?!'
He's flummoxed ... he said it, didn't he ... just cut the cake now. But Khushi is not impressed ... she wants the words, the wishes ... he's been trying the whole damn day, what with Happy Singh, hands free, haal chaal ... and he can't say two simple words which are all she wants ... she won't let him get away this easy!
When I got married, there was a tussle with my hubby, I wanted him to wish me at midnight because that was the way all my friends had done it for the last ten years ... my hubby was damned if he would do what my friends did, he wanted to be different ... and unique ... so the gifts and cake were brought the next day ... but I wasn't happy, because he hadn't been the first to wish me at midnight - the way I wanted it. So did I understand Khushi? Oh boy, yes :) ... how hard is it just to say the words? On my birthday, you do what I want ... on your birthday, I will do what you like. :)
Besides, Khushi has never been one to put up with her LG's idiosyncracies ... she made him say Sorry ... and she will make him say Happy Birthday ...
But her LG is no less ... he lights the candle ... 'come on ... let's cut the cake ...'
The candle goes out ... and LG starts to lose it ... 'hurry up, and cut the cake ... it's windy ...'
And Khushi starts to lose it too ... 'I'm not cutting any cakes ...' so there ... not till you say it ...
Arnav gets more and more angry ... 'at least blow the candle ...'
'Nope, I won't ...'
'It's your birthday, Khushi!'
Yes, he got the point ... 'it's my birthday, so I will do what I like ... I won't blow the candle, or cut the cake or eat it ... and don't you force me ...'
And he's lost it now ... temper flaring ... ah, back to their normal fights, now this he can handle ... the fiery fighting Khushi ... 'do as I say and cut the cake now ... this is the last time I'm doing this ...'
It was interesting to see how they were both so tongue-tied when it was time for soft words and romance ... and completely comfortable when back to fighting mode ...but the big difference - this time the fight was completely with Sadda Haq ... 'do as I say ..'. 'no, I won't, you have to do what I want first ...'
And Anjali approaches closer and closer with a bucket of kheer for her Chotey, he got her flowers earlier, so she reciprocates by making his favorite kheer, secure in her little bubble that her brother is completely worried about her and spending his entire day and night thinking of how to make her life easier and happier ... so what if her husband has gone, her brother is there, he will right her world again for her ... like he always does ...
While Arnav is trying his best to control his own temper and his equally tempestuous wife ... who, far from being grateful for all his efforts, is harping on the little fact that he didn't wish her ... he makes the mistake of handing her the knife and commanding her to cut the cake ... and Khushi warns him, 'don't give me that knife, I'm not responsible for what I do with it...' :))
(Have to say, I loved them here ... Sanaya's expression with the knife was hilarious!)
And Arnav reverts back to ASR and makes her cut the cake, holding her very, very close all the while ... and picks up a piece to feed her ... much to her fury ...
Just in time for Anjali to enter the room, without knocking she pushes her married brother's door open ... umm, she deserves what she gets in my opinion, just for that ... although I will add that she has been trying to block out Khushi's very existence in the house from her mind as far as possible, helped by everyone else avoiding the topic as well ... so for her, Khushi doesn't exist ...
Till she sees Arnav-Khushi very much together ... celebrating Khushi's birthday next to a beautifully decorated pool, with cake ... all that her brother has done for his wife ... while his sister's world is collapsing, and he should be only worried about his sister ...
Reality check for Anjali ... her first one ...
Even as Arnav Khushi share a small sensuous moment, as he wipes off the cake from her lip ... and tempers cool slowly ... Khushi's slower to cool than Arnav's, he is happy, he got what he wanted ... but she continues to fume and mutter soundlessly to herself ...
'What are you saying ...?!'
'I'm promising myself ... everything I will do for you on your birthday ... stuff you full of things you don't want ... turn off your AC and light the coil you're allergic to, so you can't talk ... and ... is there anything else I can do to irritate the heck out of you?'
And Arnav just grins slightly ... vintage Khushi! Besides, she just said she'd be very much there for his birthday ... :) :">
And Anjali limps back heartbroken to her room ... and her mind starts to unfreeze slowly ...
Arnav promising Anjali he would always be there for her ... his entire world is her, his Di ...
Khushi feeding Shyam kheer, leaving silently with him to unknown destination ...
Mami saying Khushi asked Shyam to divorce Anjali ...
Khushi did it all to trap Shyam ...
Arnav threw Shyam out for misbehaving with his wife ...
And we get a glimpse of how Anjali's mind has started working ... she was the most important person in her brother's life ... Khushi trapped Shyam and had him thrown out ... and Arnav threw out Shyam because he misbehaved with Khushi ...
When did Khushi take over Anjali's place in Arnav's life? Anjali was ready to magnanimously give her that place ... as long as Khushi remained suitably grateful for the honour ... when did it happen that that place was no longer Anjali's to give away?
More than Didi ki Saut ... this is about Biwi ki Saut Didi ...
The rest of the ArHi fight was actually more a filler ... to keep them apart so that they don't reach the big C yet ... :)) And to bring home to Arnav that sometimes words do matter, more than actions ...
His ILU made all the difference to Khushi, gave her the courage and the confidence to go hunt for him.
His saying HBD, something he never says to anyone else, not even to his Di, would have made her feel she was special for him ... might give her the confidence to stay the course all through the rocky road ahead with his Di ... instead of wanting to bow out of his life ...
And Anjali's thought processes start working slowly ... the flowers were for Khushi, not for her ...
She, Anjali, was Arnav's life, his world ... her world has shattered, her heart has broken, and he has forgotten about it already? He's too busy romancing his wife? Does celebrating his wife's birthday takes precedence over comforting his sister who is so shattered?
Is Khushi more important to him than she, Anjali, is?!
Anjali, this was just the first one ... many more reality checks are in store for you ... before you finally start blaming the right person ...
Thoughts:
I don't blame Anjali for feeling shattered and lost. Her world has collapsed around her ans she's still trying to pick up the pieces. She thought she was the center of her husband's world ... she is not. She comforted herself with the thought that so what if her husband left, her brother is still her rock, he will do anything for her, because his world revolves around her. And the whole family, in their effort to give her time to come to terms with the situation, unknowingly perpetuates it, by not mentioning Khushi at all, by not allowing Khushi to go near her ... so that Anjali can convince herself that Khushi is out of their lives as well, she doesn't exist ...
Besides, she asked her brother to throw Khushi out ... throw out the person who caused this entire mess ... and her brother always does what she asks ...
He made a booboo this morning, but he was properly sorry about it ... he disappeared the entire day ... he was obviously feeling so bad that he spent the day thinking about how to make it up to her ... he brought her those beautiful flowers, her favorite ... yes, her brother loves her, he will do anything for her ... because she is his world ...
Except that Reality Bites ... Di is not his world ... the flowers were not for her, they were for Khushi, whose favorite flowers they also are ...
He didn't spend the entire day in remorse that he hurt his Di ... he spent it in planning a birthday surprise for his wife ...
He is not lost and shattered because his Di's world ... he is more occupied in wooing his wife, because of whom that world shattered ...
Anjali has lost her place in her husband's life ... because Khushi trapped him ...
She has lost her place in her brother's life because he is in love with Khushi ...
I can foresee Anjali turning several shades darker :)
And the good thing is, that every time she hurts Khushi, or tries to, Arnav will be more hurt, and will do even more to make up to Khushi :)
I do feel sorry for Arnav in all this ... he has a tough time ahead between psychotic imbalanced, insecure sister, and annoyed, recalcitrant and not very secure wife. Because Khushi is not yet completely secure in her husband's love and her place in his life either ... though she's getting there ... she's learning to demand her due. And with a SIL like Anjali, she needs to do that.
Biwi ki Saut making an entry.. Lesson 3 learnt - sentiments matter more than materials...
ReplyDeleteok am dam confused about - Is poojali depressed because of Shyaamu or because she thinks Arnav loves Khushi more than her?
way to go girl -- happy that it was connected to the sorry scene ... "Aap tho ASR hai na .. Aap ke se kisi ko janam di ki badhai de sakte hai ... "
aaru, she is depressed because her 'chotey' has now become 'badey' enough to think about his wife as much as herself.. and that irks her.. understandable, earlier on, all of chotey's free time would belong to her...and now, it belongs to his beloved wifey ...
Deletedidn't get the dialogues in the precap though ... what did he say exactly to the person on the phone?
he ordered a gift which he wants to be packed in a particular way ...to write- to my beloved wife KKGSR -hayee &asked when can he get it delivered.
DeleteMads, he had booked something online and wants it addressed to his wife......thats all....
Deletethat was enuf for poojali to becum a weeping willow
*headdesk* so bitwa still hasn't learnt his lesson?! :S he STILL wants to buy gifts over the phone for his wifey?! :S anyway, I wont jump the gun until I watch the epi..
Deletehe booked it online...so dekhkar choose kiya...lets give him this one....
DeleteYes mads, agree with Geetu....poor guy...(i am not reducing any miles from RTR) but online ka zamana hain boss, itna toh banta hain.....
DeleteYep, he saw it and chose it himself ... the guy is trying ... this is all new to him :)))
DeleteBut oh boy, ASR ... you have soooo much to learn!!!
And can he start calling her Mrs Khushi Arnav Singh Raizada now? Just to irk her even more?! :)))
Deletewow Dia, wud love if he wud do that.......shiddat to that....
Deletehey bhagwaan!! CVs..for the last and final time, ArHi...ArHi..ArHi.. they are looong overdue!!! understand?? You better understand ... :S
ReplyDelete*sigh* I guess I was expecting a lot from today's episode..and arnav ka surprise tie-tie phiss hua ho ya na hua ho...mere expectations to majorr tie-tie-phiss hue!! :((
Mads I was with zero expectations and knew that KMH had to barge in .. so am in better state today..
Deleteok girls what did Bitwa tell anjali after she asked him it was her ? and before he said he known who likes red roses...
aaru he said that he got the roses for her (her as in, di).. and anjali..really, when she is supposed to think at a superfast speed she doesnt.. and now she puts two and two together and remembers all of K's flashbacks of how she has loved red roses and realises that those were indeed by Arnav for wifey dearest! funny, she is... :S
DeleteI absolutely agree mads! Very disappointed ... Is the promo thing ever going to actually air?? I so want that scene! I want her to bring up the contract and I want him to declare that he's in this to win her over for good! I want the promo!! And those kinds of scenes!!
DeleteCryanji didn't disappoint just as I expected... Unbearable... Ugh you should be crying about your faithless husband you should be asking questions not crying that your brother still loves his wife.
And seriously the last 6 months have been your brother being bothered about you please please please let him get a life so that our 8-8:30 goes better!!
Did I mention... What about the promo?? I want that scene...
Gargi, GH did mention that the scene will play out... maybe they are planning something for the 300th episode on wednesday
Deletewell it went perfectly with my expectations except the editing part ......would have preferred less of Anji but then they would have divided ArHi scene from sbs/b .... Now we will get that together .....so am happy.
DeleteThough I would have like less dialogues from K ....it was almost lecturing ....though her LG needs more of such classes
Gargs, don't raise your hopes..I don't think promo thing is ever going to air.. :( but I do agree, I want those kind of scenes!!! PLEASE, CVs.. remember what's your sure-shot solution towards TRPs!! And its NOT comic scenes of ArHi..
DeleteOn another note, loved that khushi got gifts from payal and NK.. :)) absolutely adorable they both were!! :))
I lived that Payal remembered that she had been saving up for a sari on her 25th bday and spent that money on Payal on holi... Finally Payal is becoming her old GH self:-)
DeleteWho made that shiddat about NK and Khushi and rakhi? We pretty much got that today- it wa very sweet.. Wish she'd hugged him... I really like NK he's damn sweet and I enjoy him and Arnav cuz unlike the rest of the raizadas he isn't afraid of nannav ...
oh gargs I didn't realize that .. that was my shiddat --- yep it was some sort of that kind .but i would love him to forward his hand when time for rakhi comes.
DeleteMe to wish if she had hugged him .. and love that NK did ask her about the flowers which was initiated by bitwa ...
one up there but then forcing her to cut the cake that brownie points got lost ...
Yep, so NK and Arnav made sure that Khushi knew the flowers were for her ... Arnav listening to NK's conversation was cute ... he wanted her to know that ... and he knew he'd read his Khushi correctly, she would not be angry about it. :)
DeleteArey, order another bouquet na ... one phone call, that's all it takes!
BetaJi when you don't want credit for anything you do for everyone in your family ....why do you demand it from your wife that to on her BDay and after attempted failures in wishing her, the exact thing that she wants. Kaamon Tellj???
ReplyDeleteSo Di accepts everything of AK not her KP.....this is interesting.
Cutest moment .... Aap ke janamdin pe aap bohot sara khilayenge ....andhera karke der sari agarbatti bhi jalayenge ....aapko aur kin kin cheezo se pareshani ha ....aur wo smile ....hayeeee
sama does anji accept it? I thought it was more of her denial phase...that there is someone all the more important to her chotey now..and its khushi.. when everything was rosy for her, she didn't mind this new entry in his life...but now that everythin isn't rosy..and presumably (for her) because of khushi...how can she accept the fact that her chotey has grown closer to the lady in question?
Deletemadsi
Deleteas much I understood is that she is still in complete denial with shyamu being wrong..
and her chotey is ignoring her, not just that, he has forgotten what his di has gone thru, that is what is confusing me .. has she accepted that shyam is wrong and Arnav is not with her 24/7 when she needs him hovering over her but is enjoying his married life, giving the girl in question all his attention- while she is left alone ??
or she is still in complete denial that Shyamu can't stray
well i think she does .... Otherwise why abhi abhi toh tumhare Di ke saath inta sab kuch huwa hai ...and she din't remember K accusing S ....she related the kheer scene to K's need to win her KP's trust so that she can get to A.
DeleteMy assumption ....lets see what Dia and Sandy says :)
Was wondering why Nani left this deranged girl's side for her to go around snooping her brother's room. I don't think Anjali in her right mind would have grudged her chottey his happiness. Wasn't she the one who kept throwing these two together and got upset with him every time he hurt his wife? So why is she behaving in this manner? Yes, earlier she was assured of the love and support of her creepo hubby, so she did not mind sharing her chottey with Khushi. Now her life has turned topsy turvy and in her current state she isn't able to think clearly or logically. She knows that Khushi is innocent but cannot accept that her husband has turned out to be such a kamina. She always had a low self esteem stemming from her stalled first marriage,her parents' death (which I think deep down she feels guilty for) and her handicap, as a result of which she felt eternally grateful to Shyam for accepting her. Knowing now that he did not accept her but her money (or rather her brother's money) must have dented that esteem some more. To top it she is pregnant with that kamina's child. pregnancy hormones can wreak havoc to one's logical brain, especially if one is as damaged as Anjali to start with. So needs psychological help as soon as possible but will Arnav accept that his Di's screws have turned loose?
DeleteOpti
Opti I agree 100%!! He needs and shrink pronto and preferably a smart, sweet shrink who has a thing for pretty nut jobs :-)
DeleteOpti
DeleteAgree that Anji needs psychological help .. wish that they do show that getting help isn't a taboo ..
infact I would love to see her coming out of it with a help which will make her strong to face life and world.
Opti
Deleteon second that I still feel she is in partial denial.. its like Nani said accustion were thrown but none proved so she can't accept 100% that Shyamu is guilty... if he is so is Khushi,
So i think its Anji's argument which will lead to Shyam's re entry --- like if her bro can stay with a person who has been wrong what ever the reason may be , so she can hence will ask for shyam into RM ... since there are no factual proofs that will indeed prove VRL guilty..
ok what am i ranting ??
Opti it was night .. so maybe Nani went to sleep
DeleteMy problem was with Anji ... woman you barge into your married chotes room without even knocking .... we know they aren't upto anything .... she DOES NOT !!!
Though I found her making kheer for chote as he got her her favourite flower very sweet. That scene had a lot of affection in it.
hey Gals.....
ReplyDeletelots of Anji today.....finally she knew that its Khushi's birthday......and saw them cutting the cake.....also realized that the rose were for her, and threw the bouquet.......
they are slowly turning her more grey...not just an mental case....
liked the episode....these two are awesome...their fight just makes the scene come alive....the way he was ordering her to cut the cake, n she adamant that its her birthday and he cant force her for anything......and he finally catching hold of her hand and making it cut the cake.....khushi told Arnav that all she wants was a heart-felt wish....
also he heard her telling NK that she was happy that Arnav's bouquet bought a smile to anji's face......
when Anji witnessed the forcefully cake cutting ceremony, i thought she will take it as khushi not loving arnav but kept by his side forcefully.....also her fb's were khushi feeding VLR kheer.....so what does anji thinks, that khushi wanted shyam and is forced by arnav or that khushi is out to destroy everything close to anji...any idea, girls ??
Geetu, i am not sure if she has watched the forceful cutting ceremony, from her FBs, it only shows they were together...also she did not come in but if she has registered that aspect....what u r saying above is in abs sync....she can well feel that Khushi is the poison in her/their life
Deletehmm....that wud be so difficult to solve.....
Deleteits sad to see anjali like this....she witnessed khushi's love for arnav when he was out of town....how come she isnt thinking of that at all.....
she never thought of khushi as a conniving person, so there was no way she can assume that khushi was acting that time....
Geetu: I think Anjail sort of saw her as the girl who came between Arnav and her and Shyam and her.
DeleteI am okay with Anjali's track.
She has had 2 days to deal with this. Arnav has had 4 months, so it is easier for him to move on.
When Arnav found out he wasnt exactly rational about it was he? he went and married Khushi and it took him 4 months to figure out.
So by that standards, Anjali's reaction is perfectly fine.
geeta to think good when everything is bad in your world is not possible ... not immediately at least
Deletewhere she can find fault in chote, his actions and intentions ... the guy who had done everything and more in terms of both relation and living... khushi is an outsider
Shwetha *hug* : yeah, its been just 2 days for her....if she thinks of khushi as just the reason, then its true cause she is the reason (unfortunately) and that wud be easy.....cause time will eventually heal her....but if she thinks tat khushi did all this on purpose then bumpy road ahead for arhi....
DeleteSama : you are abs right if she can think that her chotte has forgotten her totally, toh khushi kya cheez hai...
Geetu,
Delete'so what does anji think, that khushi wanted shyam and is forced by arnav':
*surprised!*
I felt this way too.
Even if she does not believe it now, it looked like she can be easily led into that line of thought!
If Arnav had wished Khushi, she would have got the biggest gift ever for her birthday because she knows he never wishes anyone for their birthday. So by wishing her he would have shown her that she does matter enough to him that he is willing to change himself and his quirky behaviour only for her. Getting a cake or lighting up the pool side is no big deal for a man like ASR who has money to throw around but getting himself to say the three words she so wanted to hear from him (no not 'I love you but' 'Happy birthday Khushi') would have required so much more effort from him and so it would have been so much more valuable to her. alas, ASR being ASR had to goof up on the one thing he had to do but could not. Loving his long walk to redemption. In this process he will turn out to be a better man. Reminded me of a line from 'As good as it gets' - You make me want to be a better man'
ReplyDeleteOpti
I loved Arnav's smile when she tells him how she will trouble him on his b'day....*shiddat* to that....it was as if Arnav couldn't wait for her to do all that she promised....
ReplyDeleteFinally glad that An ji is verbalising her feelings....always the first step of progression (or regression, depending on which way u look at it)
Anji has been dissected so much before her spoken words that when she actually speaks, i am almost went tongue-tied. for a while but i recovered soon enuf...I would say she pretty summed up what we have all been talking abt....
To Aaru's question on what is troubling her more...i would say....she is not considering VLR the guilty party at all...atleast it doesn't seem so; her point therefore is how can Arnav spend a romantic eve with his wife when she has suffered so much, esp considering Arnav's promise...."baki duniya se mera koi matlab nahin, meri asli duniya toh aap ho" so she is asking what happened to that promise of urs....Its keeping in very much with her character....remember she said to Khushi during that London trip thing some dialogue like ....if he has not told me, how can he be teling u"
The fact of the matter, Arnav bitwa never told her that meri asli duniya aap ho until Khushi comes in my life...thats the problem....
me too loved the smile Rekha.... lagta hai bitwa ka birthday 6 months khatam hone ke baad hoga.....so he knows that she has to be around to do all that...
Delete'The fact of the matter, Arnav bitwa never told her that meri asli duniya aap ho until Khushi comes in my life...thats the problem....' *rofl*
some reason i loved the way he shoved the cake in her mouth...looked cute in a way
See everything was going fine....then he saw that bag....
DeleteI wanted to scream at Arnav....at the start of the epi, when she came into the room, my thot was Arjun bane raho....u need concentration...to wish Khushi....don't muck by getting derailed by other thots.( i was thinking abt Anji as KMH, never expected it will be a bag) i was thinking gadho...aur bhi bag kharid lena...why are u fussing, ASR?
Anyways, we got Shweths' ASR style pyaar....*rofl*
Me tooo :D :D
Deleteloved how easily he lost it .... mein yeh last time kar raha hoon ... but then again lit the candle ... placed knife in her hand &her retort ... iss churi se hum abhi kuch bhi kar saktein hain ... makes her cut the cake and moreover shoved it in ... at the end wiped it off her lip .... Haaayyyeeeee
Ok I loved the whole scene
A gloatwa ve too ... he did lose it very soon .... not his cup of tea :D :D
Geetu, according to the passport his b'day falls on 9th of August. So khushi ka badla is not far away. :)
DeleteBut Ananya, 14th feb they got married so july 14th 6 months over.....so she has to extend the contract to take badla....hehehehe
DeleteArre nahin! According to that: 6 months in actual=4 months in (N)arnialand.
DeleteSo badladay...I mean b'day may fall well within the contract. Hopefully!!!
I missed the epi after the cake cutting as somebody had dropped in. :((
the last part was just poojali weeping on how can her chotte forget her...and what happened to his promise that she is his world...she also threw the bouquet away.....
DeleteThanks for the update!
DeleteI think this is a natural reaction of any possessive nanad when she realizes that somebody else has become more important in her bro's life...normally the married ones take it in a positive stride as they have an equally loving husband. Its single ones who create a fuss and show insecurity. That is why I was comparing Anjali to Babli the other day.
ananya, perfectly put. yes, that is indeed anjali right now.. when she had a husband to be happy about, she was more than happy to push chotte with khushi.. but right now she sees her brother put his wife's happiness before his sister's..especially when said sister has gone through a terrible thing.. she is shocked enough to think that nothing else happened in the meantime..
Deletei am sure the last time this happened, her chotte put everything aside(including his personal demons) and helped pamper di's wishes..
must be a bitter pill for her to swallow.
Sandy!! Today's forceful cake scene totally reminded me of beauty and te beast when he forces we to stay and spend time with him and eat and she's absolutely obstinate and then later when he opens up to her and starts changing she falls for him...
ReplyDeleteI guess I am the only one who feels very different about the epi today.
ReplyDeleteI get it Khushi wanted him to wish her. She didn't like the whole bag thingy, Fair enough.
Why didn't she think for a second and appreciate that, he put those decorations cos she would like them and he actually associated their memory with them........The new year's eve, the whole we will spend the year together thing, the cake, the filmy ambience......
He did think and did something that she would like in their home, in their bedroom, by the poolside which holds so many memories.
She didn't want the Raizada family to know about her family. Did the guy let it go and keep quiet about it?
No he informed Nani, so everyone can atleast wish her.
NK gets her a gift and she says he will be there for her. She says, I understand or Even if you hadn't said it I would have understood.
They why cannot she understand what he is struggling to say and is trying to convey it by actions.
Hasn't ASR always struggled with words and shows his concern, affection,love by actions.
Yes ofcourse it would have meant a world to her if he had wished her, but when you can understand and accept gifts from NK, WHY Not from Arnav.
I get the bag thing, Totally!!
Her bag tore, he immediately decided to get her a new bag, practical gift maybe but he did want to gift her something.
All the words sounded a bit hollow to me.
She knew and understand right the flowers were for her and not for Di, so why this whole hungama?
If the whole funda of not the gift but the thought behind it counts, then I think Considering who ASR is as she has known him, it should have mattered right?
that would have ment khushi melting into Arnavs arm ... time is not right for that ... or maybe we are in for a dialogue from K tomorrow ... humein maaf kardijiye arnavji humein ye sab aapko bol na pada... who knows :S
DeleteYep in a normal situation absolutely but here she's hurt and upset I think anything short of actual words from isn't going to cut it...
DeleteAnyway I'm rooting for a long RTR and very little do drama...
Shiddat pls let the promo and such scenes happen
Shwetha, i think it all matters...and she knows it...but its just like pre wedding days when she wudn't accept that he is good.....cause now that he has raised the contract thingy again, so she doesnt want another heart break and is keeping her feelings locked.....
DeleteShweths, agree with you.. although I think that all those words were coming out of the fact that she thinks that bitwa still considers their relation as a contract marriage.. I think that is where all that bitterness is coming from..warna bitiya toh would have immediately melted at whatever he has done for her.. I could actually see the hint of gratefulness on her face, until bitwa brought up the topic of the bag.. had he not brought that up, probably the scene would have been different.. then again, they had to stretch that scene for anji to come and visualise them..
DeleteSN - ASR is truly Arnav Sandwich Raizada now.. if he tries to keep di happy and shouts at wifey, wifey gets mad...if he wants to win back wifey to keep her happy, di gets mad.. poor guy!
Sama: I dont want her to melt in his arms, Bitwa has to really work harder for that. But tonight somehow she appeared callous and threw it in his face.....Oh well Karma is biting mr.ASR's A**:)
DeleteGargi: Yaar when she understood the flowers were for her, appreciated that he got them for her and kept quiet for Di, I WOULD have rather the dialogues were worded differently, pata nahin yaar.........Maybe tomorrow she will acknowledge and appreciate his efforts when he is not around.
Geetu: Ah, now I see it somewhat, hugs bey!
My exact sentiments shwetha... i totally dint understand khushi's behavior today.. she doesnt need to hear the exact words from NK, she is not upset about the flowers coz it made Di happy... so why not spare the guy, after all he did do every thing for her. he did remind her about the NY thing... he put up lights to make her happy, he ordered red roses for her.... he got her a bag as soon as he got to know her other bag tore... he let know the entire household that its her bday and made sure she got nani's ashirvad.....
Deletekhushi knows his actions speak louder than his words.. and today his actions were screaming out his love for her. why does she want him to verbally wish her??
he vowed to woo back his wife, but in that process should he really lose himself?? i definitely dont want him to be the brainless blindly loving chotey... i want him to be ASR who is caring, affectionate, and loving towards his wife retaining all his core characteristic features including his flaring temper. i want him to be himself with khushi... i want him to be loved not just for being arnav but for being asr plus his takniki kharabhis...
i have read somewhere that u like people for the all the good in them... but you love them for all their flaws because without the flaws they are not complete...
Arnav never seek for credit for anything he does for others but he does with Khushi .... similarly Khushi wants the exact thing that makes her happy from her LG.... with others they can let go things... not between them
Deletealso, I think that Arnav will probably end up wishing her happy birthday with the red rose and a forehead kiss that they'd shown in SBS/SBB.. and K is not sleeping, so she hears that and then apologises the day after for saying that to him? :S who knows..
Deleteone thing positive about Anji KMH is that atleast she is moving in some direction now...tomo she is most likely to spit it out to chotey that he doesn't love her anymore and that he cares only abt khushi .. let't see whether Arnav reacts to it as Chotey or as Arnav himself..
See Shweths...ur points are abs valid....., soem of the thots u mentioned crossed my mind too.....
Deletethe whole problem is with that "happy birthday" thingy.....we have not got a decent answer on why those words were not forthcoming from ASR...(assuming they are important for someone whose bday it is)
At one level they wanted to establish that Khushi does not care for the frills...and at other level they wanted to establish that ASR will do everything in his power to make the day right for Khushi though he will do it in his own style....
Naturally, there will be fireworks......
at the end of this track, i guess
K will understand that A is making an attempt which goes against his nature Or that he has issues becos of his past
Arnav will understand that for Khushi words matter a lot and he will ponder over why he can't say those words....
Im hoping thats what it will culminate in...a better understanding of who they are really
Mads: To be honest, I completely forgot that he brought up the contract thingy now it makes lot more sense.
DeleteRekha, I totally forgot the contract thingy and also she is usually who is more than the gift the thought matters kind of girl, so I was confused why she is not seeing the effort he is putting.
DeleteI think that gift will also be tai tai phiss either cos of him or cos of Anjali, so he will simply gift her the rose as per sbs.
Rain sequence is on wednesday their 300 episode, Rain by the pool perhaps?
Krish: i have read somewhere that u like people for the all the good in them... but you love them for all their flaws because without the flaws they are not complete...
DeleteAwwwwwwwwww, so beautifully put. I am guessing the guilt will come later. They both are alike, say things first and regret later, lol.
I will be very honest, I half expected IF to be up in arms how she was insensitive etc etc....And I LOLed cos everyone is too distracted with Anjali:)
@Rekha... agree with the last para! :) I think this is what it is all about... yes, they love each other the way they are ... but to live together (considering how diametrically opposite they are), is that enough? They need to know what the other person's needs are in order to live in harmony... for khushi, it might be easy since she has always thought about the needs of people around her .. but for Arnav, its all the more difficult, because he has never given all that a thought at all ... for his di, anything he did would be rewarded with a smile..or probably, he is soo used to di's needs that it comes as naturally as breathing to him.. but for khushi and her needs, he needs some time.. :))
DeleteRain sequence is pakka news????
DeleteI totally understand Khushi. Yes, Arnav did a lot of things for her but these are things which he can easily buy with his money. He did get her a bag when he came to know that it was torn. Now that is thoughtful of him but is it enough? Not to her because he just ordered it over the phone and his man friday got it for him. He lit up the pool side with lights because she had decked up her house with lights on new years day. Again very thoughtful but then it is not too difficult for him to do that, especially with NK to help with it too. Now wishing her on her birthday. Now that is the simplest thing for anyone but ASR. She knows it is very difficult for him because he has never wished anyone in all his 28 years of existence. Now had he done what he had never done before, it would have shown her how special she is. All his acts showed how much he cared but it did not show how special she was.
DeleteI have no doubt that she loves him with all his flaws but that does not mean she shouldn't try to rectify some of those flaws. After all if you truly love the person you would want that person to be a better human being. that is why she did not grudge him letting his Di think that the bouquet was for her.
Yes, he let Nani know it was Khushi's birthday and let everyone wish her but he himself couldn't wish her?
Yes, she knows he loves her but she wants him to show how special she is. Why is the guy having trouble doing that? I do hope there are most such jatkas for ASR and he learns to exhibit his feelings not only in actions but also in words.
I don't think he will lose himself in his quest of winning her. He will hopefully turn into a better person. His rough edges may get smoothened but his basic characteristics will remain the same (or hope it does).
Opti
Sama: Star plus even put a banner on its site about Arhi romance from their first rain sequence.
DeleteNews from Redux last week itself was it would be one of the hottest sequences.......And it seems they had water lorries and GH also tweeted that he didnt like writing rain sequences cos apart from waste of water , actors get sick.
So all things said and done if it escapes SP Scissors, we are in for something special on wednesday.....It has already been shot..let us see what we get.
wow shweths.. Keeping my fingers tightly crossed! Although how in the current scenario are they going to manage a rain sequence I am not sure... :S but who's complaining?! :D
Deletemaybe she will throw another tantrum about expensive gifts and ASR will lose it so bad that he will go all quiet ... phir biwi jaiyegi poolside mein manane ... aur lo shuru hogayi barish !!!
Deleteok back from ArHiland ... lets see what cvs have in store.
BG shiddat to "escapes SP Scissors" all of it :D
Shweths and Krish, your posts reminded me of one of my old posts back in Feb, around the bangle episode time ... when I said ...
DeleteShe wants him to say the words,
He wants her to understand, why does he need to say it ...
In this case, it's more ... she actually accepted his stammering as the spoken words in GH, and said thanks, and he was the one who kept changing it to haa ... Happy Singh .. hands free ...
So now she's annoyed, well then, say the damn words, why is it so difficult?! And they both are equally ziddi ... she is no less!
Though I also felt she could have been a little more touched with the whole lights and cake bit ... especially as he remembered that she liked lights ... but I think, by then, and after his bag ka blooper, Khushi was just too annoyed ... and the bag thing also kicked in Opti's chain of thought ... that he did everything that money could buy, but he couldn't simply wish her. That would have made it the most special for her, knowing he did something that he doesn't do for anyone else.
Funny though ... again like NY, Arnav pooh-poohed NK's idea, and then followed exactly that ... give her flowers and cut a cake!
Shwetha, the same PH was shooting a rain song for Surveen Duggal ... are we sure the rain song was really for ArHi? They don't really seem in romantic mode as of now ... is that news from Redux reliable?
Deleteif my husband tried to force feed me cake on my birthday, i would kick him where it hurts and not speak to him for a week.. glad khushi dint go that far!
Deleteand yes, that was perfectly the beauty and beast scene.. but why was arnav smiling throughout? he thought it was a joke? does he even understand the majboori of a girl under threat of a contract marriage and forcefully made to do whatever he wishes? with no say in the matter? she cannot even refuse to cut the cake on her own birthday? the beast, who professes to love her, does not even grant her that one tiny liberty?
khushi did not forget all the things he did today.. she thinks that all those things become irrelevant when it is HIS wish being carried out, not hers.
it is her birthday today.. heaven knows how much love she got at her own house for her birthday.. see how payal gave her the gift? so much love..
and here is her husband, who shares hearbeats with her, forcing her to cut a cake and taste it. the nainsafi!!!
she needs to go a long way to understand how her husband shows his love.. she has never understood it.. yet.
i felt really bad for arnav when she rejected his gifts and all his declarations of love(!) and stomped away.
but then, what he did was 100% wrong in my hisab-kitab.
okay,, clarifying.. i would never kick my hubs because he is awfully sweet on my birthday.
Deletearnav did do may things, far out of his comfort zone, for her birthday.. but does khushi know that? it is her first birthday at RM.. she does not know how/if people there celebrate birthdays..
i did not understand how bitwa can say "today's your birthday" but not "happy birthday"
i did not understand why anjali had to come into their room to see them through the poolside windows.
i definitely know why the dining table wall art was on the first floor landing.. and i know why the room seems to have shifted again.. it was in one place for too long, so hogwarts decided to shift rooms around again.
i LOVED what they did with the lights today.. the poolside was magical.. decoration team, take a bow!
today, i was impressed to see anjali cooking kheer with no help whatsoever.. yesterday's milk seems to have done her a ton of good! and i love that RM is totally deserted whenever anyone needs privacy. and i am less than impressed to see anjali cooking kheer --only because her chotte bought her flowers.. is she keeping accounts for love, too?
today, i am super impressed with how arnav detected that the bag was wet.. and seriously, his nok jhok voice is a brand of its own!
i loved the whole cake scene, and it was eerily reminiscent of khushi's ILU bottle dream. in fact, i think, if khushi was not wearing that peach number, she would have been wearing the bali hotel-wala dress. arnav bending to light the candle.. they used the same angle, even the same matchbox! but the reactions were far different. will we see the continuation similar to the dream?
Shwetha,
DeleteThe gift on order is the next day morning, well past her birthday. May be it is a peace offering?
I am hoping too that WEdnesday wil be a god one on account of 300th epi, and also because they wasted so much time on Anji the beginning of the week.
Rain hug??? Without promos airing yet, on wednesday? Not sure.
Dia,
I agree with you on so many points here.
Jaya,
Great to see you back in action as BBE though you are travelling.
the rain scene is one big joke by GH/PH on us poor souls, i tell u....even the tanker spoiler was so innocuously put out....why was the epi shot in advance....they never do that...and why the secrecy.....
DeleteGH on IPK
ReplyDeletehttp://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3096719
Sama, Hi5! :D I posted the same thing at the same time.. :P haha..
DeleteHi5!! >:D<
DeleteGanesh Hegde's new tweet -
ReplyDelete"it may come across as hindrnc but the concpt of IPK was didi ki souten- a man torn btwn 2 women he loved n his sis torn btwn 2 men she loved"
Ok, I just realised...if DB's contract negotiation stuff wouldn't have come up in new, I would have felt completely different about the entire enji track ... DB sorta spoiled it for me.. :S though she is understandable..if this is what she was promised, then this is what she should get.. and this is what we are getting to watch to!
Then again, Sanaya is sooo talented and attractive that she is absolutely impossible to pay attention to anything else once she is on screen.. if they had taken an actress other than Sanaya, people wouldn't have reacted the way they do now.. because they think Sanaya is the main lead of the show...whereas she is actually, technically according to this storyline, just the love interest of this guy in question.. also, not to mention, the sizzling chemistry b/w ArHi/SaRun..make it impossible to visualise IPK w/o the sizzling love track..
the ArHi chemistry is a double edged sword for the main storyline.. :)
DB did spoil half the fun ... though I have no problem with Anjali .... I can't stand DB anymore. Last sbs she was talking about tweety bird ... it just irked me :S
Deletehahahah Sama! :P can I say I found your last statement cute?! :P *hugs* the way you cribbed about her .. lol.. :)
DeleteSame here Sama, DB has really irked a lot of people.... so much that we are not sympathizing with anji the way we shud....
DeleteBut Sanaya is the little magician, her presence just lights up the screen......she is the reason i started watching the show....infact i shudder at the thought that most of the ph guys wanted prachi desai as khushi....god bless the only person who insisted for sanaya
geetu, trust me, if prachi desai were khushi, the CVs would have managed to pull of the original storyline w/o any problem and interference from ArHi fans...because I can BET you, ArHi wouldn't be the phenomenon that they are now.. which is why I said that in choosing SaRun to play ArHi they have in a way jeopardized their original storyline.. :)
Deleteyea Mads, totally agree with what u said....
DeleteI second that, I wouldn't be watching the show if it wasn't for Sanaya ... she and the ArHi chemistry are the USP of the show. I do remember a huge discussion I had with some MJHT friends though, wondering whether Sanaya was doing right by taking this role, because like you said, mads, she is technically just the love interest of the guy.
DeleteBut having said that ... all the articles from the start, have called Barun and Sanaya the LEADS ... and Daljeet and Abhaas the parallel leads. These four make up the main story - but BS/SI are the romantic couple, so they qualify as the main leads.
So Khushi's role was always strong ... and if you see the way it plays out, Khushi is actually the connecting link of the entire show. She has strong, unique and well-defined relationships with each and every member of the family ... and with all the other three, and so does Anjali. While Shyam and Arnav are mainly linked with the two women, but Khushi and Anjali have their own bond too.
Though honestly, it's more like Biwi Ki Saut Didi ... Biwi was never the other woman willingly, but Didi is becoming the other woman very strongly!
Dia ... that's exactly the reason I am so irked with DB ... in all her early interview she has stated herself as parallel lead not the main lead .... why such a sudden fuss over "I was promised the lead of the show" in media with a half baked quitting drama ... Stupid woman!
DeleteMadsie totally agree with your statement about ArHi/SaRun chemistry .... Prachi Desai she is still pretty decent ... you should check out other options they had for ArHi specially Khushi .... but chalo they did get it right at the end
Two different visions given by people involved with IPK...One put out by Gul and other now in common knowledge, ratified by GH
DeleteWhich is the correct version....rather whose vision has been diluted/altered/watered down?
Just a thot, and i don't know if my premise is right
Perhaps TRP audiences will go for the Didi ki saut version....romance does not seem to high on their priority for entertainment choices....they are happy to see larger than life drama of the kind that they probably see in their lives or they are eager to see scenarios play out....friction in relationships other that the romantic ones.....for them man-woman relationship is dusted and dried....shaadi ho gayi, romance is out of the window, where is the time to dwell on such notions....that too a love story so diffi to comprehend.....
Gul's vision seemed to highlight the aspect of why the man, who shunned love hitherto....found anchor in his life after meeting an unusual woman.....I can't accept that "maula tu hi bata" was meant for just a love interest in that story....it seemed to indicate that this is an unusual story of lovers who can't live together even as they can't be apart. Agreed, the complication in their love story gained ground esp considering the didi ki saut complication....
But GH calling this love story a hindrance while citing the so called original premise sounds very hollow....Can't accept they spent so much time on a love story that was only a side element.....The better thing to say would be having reached an important stage in the love story, we are working to include how this has affected the man's other important relationship...
As makers they have every right to put out the vision that best describes their story but am surprised at the poor articulation of such a superior product!! Ab maula tu hi bata......
Iss pyaar ko kya naam doon - a star-crossed love story presenting an interesting contrast of personalities entwined in a relationship swinging between love and hate.
DeleteThis is what they promoted it as .... a more appealing version to mass audience than "a man torn btwn 2 women he loved n his sis torn between 2 men she loved" or "journey of two siblings to find their soulmate" which may have been discussed in interviews as Dia said they did know and debated whether sanaya was doing the right thing by taking up this role.
Gul's 200th episode celebration interview -
It was debated to be --- Vaidehi or Didi ki Saut
Vaidehi - Story from Khushi's POV
A selfless girl who will guide these two siblings to find their soulmates in her sacrificing ways
Didi ki Saut - Story from Arnav's POV
A stubborn man who will not let either sister or his love to drift away from him despite their equation.
Somewhere they found a premises in IPKKND to merge both POV beautifully and give us ArHi we are totally in love with.
Vaidehi had played out is ready for the final showdown.
Didi ki Saut kicked off well with terrace scene but the drag we have been subjected to had left us impatient. Its time to get that moving and reach vaidehi because both needs to be played out at the same time.
2 main leads - Arnav Khusdhi
2 parallel leads - Shyaam Anjali
Arnav Khushi Shyaam have reached second phase of the story.
Anjali has been stuck at phase one due drag post marriage. Anjali can reach the second phase only when she gets her reality check. That can happen only when she sees ArHi together in their intimate moment .... uuummmm do they have any ... yes exactly the way they have cut the cake, their first ever husband and wife doing something together moment ... other silent understanding looks between them are beyond anyones understanding ... definitely not enough to pick Anjali's bubble.
They cannot reach the climax until all four characters are at the same level. Moreover they cannot play out ArHi's second phase till Anjali has reached the start point.
This has always been ArHi sotry and will be so. With no importance to shyaam and anjali ArHi (don't throw chappals) is worthless.
The only problem here is ... PH needs to put a "lagaam" on cast and crew shooting their mouth in media.
I don't know if I made any sense ... this is how I see IPK.
During ArHi marriage I became desperate to know what will happen next .... MU which I thought will be on mends way in a month took ages but thanks to my desperation R&R let me keep up with the story ... which had not faltered... they dragged, they din't execute well at times but story remained what it was suppose to be.
So I want it to play out & enjoy the episodes as it come. And keep on reminding self that this is a daily soap which airs 5 times a week and has to run for years .... This is NOT my unabridged classic
Bottom line .... I am loving it! I seriously don't mind the media chaos as long as I have the characters in character and with the story. Ok off I go.
Very well put, Sama! Loved your post! And very true, without Shyam and Anjali, ArHi story is nothing ... no story at all.
DeleteGH said that Anjali is coming across as a hindrance, not the love story ... the point he was making is that while people see Anjali as a hindrance in the main story - Arhi, Anjali is and was always a part of the main story.
Sama, interesting post.....
DeleteLooks like i misunderstood the "hindrance" word in GH's tweet....LOL
Sama,
DeleteYou have put it so rightly, I feel.
Sama, Dia,
'without Shyam and Anjali, ArHi story is nothing ... no story at all'
*applause*
Don't be in a hurry to get rid of them for the love story to move forward.They are the ones who will keep the love story alive.
Any love story is incomplete without a hindrance. The more, the better.
Hugs Dia, Su and Rekha :D
DeleteGlad I made sense.
Ok I logged on to IF
ReplyDeleteAll gone crazy .... I don't understand them !! :O
they are irritating the hell out of people of IPK in social network &posting only the outburst from GH and making the whole crowd even madder
that guy is right ... they have a story to deliver and its not only ArHi and the fact that they know their character and won't ruin their baby for anything .... ok he went a bit too far by saying "dekhna hai toh dekho" but I don't think it came from him just like that.
though I do agree with "dekhna hai toh dekho"
itne dino baadh toh story right track pe ayi hai ... ab bhi agar shikayat hai toh just leave it .... 100 of channels waiting your remote
Me too. I don't understand!
DeleteWhat does IF want?
Lots of romantic scenes, big C... then what? Another MU?
How can ARHI ever have another MU again? 'Is vishwaas pe vishwaas dilaya" It is all about trust now.
If IF had their way, the show would be over in a month.
Su not to worry ... there are lots of things we fans want .. cvs will do it their way ... only interfering force can be SP itself and SP had seen first hand what damage they did to their own product .... SP will not dare ever do it again.
DeleteFunniest thing is .... few days back there were mails sent to PH demanding an explanation "why is the story moving so fast .... do you intend to finish it off?!" :O :O
Satyanash !!
(How cute was Khushi when she said it?! :D)
Ladies you guys seem to have said it all - anyhow - my take on the epi:
ReplyDeleteNK -did not like him when he was introduced, he was kind of annoying! but since the Kidnapping - I love the guy - NK, Aaj dil khush kar diya tumnay
Anji - so far i have been her supporter but i kind of got irritated with her today - i can understand her anger at KKG (after all in her mind she is the culprit, the one person who ruined it all) - I can also understand that she is still not accepting her husband was a creep - fine
but what i cannot understand is her reaction to her brother - she is not angry that ODB hit her husband but angry because he said 'meri biwi say batameezi katrnay klay liya' - she did not mind the 'for hurting my di bit' - Also she accepts that she has gone through a lot and like typical ostrich mentality, is not angry at her husband but angry at ASR for "forgetting so soon!" oh i understand that you try to protect the person you love the most by teaching yourself to get angry at the non-issue by others rather than the major wrong done by the loved one - but still got irritated with Anji today
- The forced cake feeding part - i am sorry - did not like - that was plain obsessive - (Anjam kind of way) - creepy and not nice
Rest of the epi - Aaaawwww - so sweet :D:D:D
mons, anjali remembered the second slap today, that slap underlines the fact that bitwa gives equal importance to his wife.. anji did not know that he did..
Deleteshe thought she was the only woman in her brothers life.. even before london trip, she has been seeing that arnav fights with khushi, khushi doesnot know when arnav left for london... ODG was not that important.. his meds TQ gave, his clothes TQ packed.. everything changed in two weeks (and yes, the equation only changed in the two weeks.. it was the i love you that changed it all!)
Mona,
DeleteWith you on NK: Growing fond of him now.
NK, please stay around at least till Rakshabandhan. May be we can get to see Khushi tying a rakhi on you.The other sibling pair is going to be so OTT this Rakshabandhan.We viewers need something to balance it out!
Jaya,
Very nicely put.
This, along with the epi takes me back to the old Q of who will ASR choose? Almost wondering if he will be forced to choose Anji because:
1. Anji demands it with lot of things to back up her claim.
2. Khushi wants to leave, she cannot bear to come in between them.
Jaya,
Deleteu pointed out the timeline beautifully....
In effect, it only underscores what we have been saying that Anji was perhaps ok with that status quo as it still kept her number one on the list...she did not go about sparing a thot why it is so? the only concession she made was about medicines...
The turn around is unpalatable for her...If she was in her senses, she shuld have fought with Arnav and asked him why did u accept Khushi's claim over my husband's.....she hasn't done that....and i wonder why?
Advice to ODG:
ReplyDeleteDear girl - you have a damn rich husband - dont teach him all the wrong ideas - 'wishes are all i want' kind of stuff! - am telling you girl dont spoil him - accept all he gives with good grace and demand more ;)
And Advice to ODB - once a gift is given, its given - dont keep rubbing the price tag in!!!
DeleteHahahahha great advice Mona;-)
DeleteAmazing observation power .. lol
ReplyDeletehttp://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3097176
LOL i just wrote that and someone already found pictures!!! and the mosquito coil too!! ROFL!!
DeleteRambling...
ReplyDeleteEver wondered how a person who has lost his or her spouse in an accident or war and never had closure feels?
If you've seen the movie P.S. I Love You, there is a boast scene b/w 3 pals and another scene between 2 friends where one is getting married and the other who lost her husband and is just unable to ease out of the grief. Their conversation is somewhere on the lines of "Were you upset and angry that your life seemed to have stopped while all of us seem to have moved forward?" And the young widow said yes. In the boat scene, one friend got engaged to be married and another got pregnant and the yougn widow cannot believe they did not tell her on one hand and on another she is so annoyed that they are all so happy while she is drowing in sorrow. Is she wrong? Is she to be sympathised with? Is she delusional? Or is she just human?
Why do they say that when someone dies or when something bad happens, the person most affected needs to cry?
In a pervious storm, you found support with one anchor. Then you felt blessed to have 2. Suddenly another storm struck and you lost one but were relieved to be told you stil had the other. You cling to that one with all your might. But suddenly you realize that the second anchor was also an illusion and you are now adrift and alone.
In life, when you focus on a any/new relationship older / other relationships do suffer in terms of time and quality. It is the way of life but painful even in the best of times and when you are in full senses. But when asked to face this reality when you are already weakened it is nothing less than a storm on your shores. Instant reaction?
In India we largely talk of grief in terms of sympathy or we think teh person needs alone time. We rarely ever consider therapy. Sometimes the best therapy family can give is to continue status quo till things stabilize and then gradually ease the person to see a consultant to get it all out. Heck even marriage counselling is a stigma by and large.
I brought up widows to start with because when you are one and there are festiavls in the house, that first year without your spouse by your side and being told you cannot participate and you have to cede to others is painful. You know it is he right thing to do but there is anger and jealousy for the otehr son "lucky" to have it all. At that time how easy is it to blame it all on the person who succeeds you. How easy is it to blame that this person is out to eclipse you and usurp your place in teh hosue and relationships? And how tough does it all become when one you considered closest to you, seems to be not as affected by your plight and he usually would be and to top it off seems to be lying about caring for you?
Are you Right? Wrong? Just Being Human?
"Baithe the kinaare pe
Maujon ke ishaare pe
Hum khele toofaano se
Is dil ke armaano se
Humko yeh maaloom na tha
Koi saath nahi deta
Maajhi chhod jaata hai
Saahil chhot jaat hai"
SN: Not taking sides or judging. Just made me pause and think.
Sandy lovely take.. its is something or anything to try to hold so that you can move.. every relationship changes with time, with every new one the old one gets effected. the old feel left out and unneeded while the new wants to make a mark ..
Deletebeautifully put and can relate it because each one of us have gone thru this one point or other ...
Sandy.. Have been following this blog for couple of weeks.. Wanted to write quite a few times but somehow didnt..
DeleteToday, after reading your comment, I just had to write something.. Just couldnt help it.. I totally agree with your take here.. I hate Anjali many times.. But yesterday, she was devastated.. Nowhere to turn to.. No wonder she is totally broke..
N yes.. P.S.ILU happens to be my all time favorite movie for the intense n heartfelt relationship the leads share..
I dont think I need to tell You this.. But you and Dia write beautifully.. :)
Sandy, beautiful take as usual!
DeleteI think the most relevant part is the last ...
"And how tough does it all become when one you considered closest to you, seems to be not as affected by your plight and he usually would be and to top it off seems to be lying about caring for you?"
That is what is hurting Anjali the most right now ... the fact that her brother is NOT AS DEVASTATED as she is, if not more than her ... that he is, in fact, celebrating a happy occasion in private with his wife ... that he is even in the mood to be happy about anything at all ... when she, Anjali is devastated, how can he be anything but that!
and by extension, therefore, that Khushi is more important to him than Anjali is, at this moment, when Anjali is the one who needs him the most ...
Is it a selfish viewpoint? Yes, certainly ...
Anjali is shattered ... yes.
She thinks Arnav Khushi have had a normal relationship for the last four months, with their ups and downs, but then she always knew they fought like cats and dogs anyway. She has no clue that this is the starting point of their own relationship as well, after a lot of downs and very few ups. In which case, she is justified in expecting both the full attention, and especially Arnav's ... yes.
Arnav has always been there for her whenever she needed him and she needs him the most now, because her other anchor, her husband is missing ... yes.
And I reiterate ... it IS selfish ... but then when your own world has shattered, it's difficult to be selfless ... Anjali was perfectly happy to hand over Arnav to Khushi when she was confident that he was hers to hand over ... now she suddenly gets this feeling that Arnav is not hers to hand over at all ... and this when her husband has just abandoned her as well. So she's alone, she's insecure ... and she wants to know that her brother is there for her like always ...
and she finds that he's NOT there for her like always ...
I sympathise with her, I will give her more time to recover, I fully expect her to resent Khushi more and more ... because she will see Khushi as the root of all her troubles ... and the more Arnav tries to woo Khushi, the more Anjali will be hurt .... the more Anjali hurts Khushi, if she does, the more Arnav will try to make up to Khushi ...
Complete vicious cycle being set up here ... all three are justified in their own place ... but Anjali has to be the one to accept reality ... now that Arnav is married, his priorities WILL change, and she has to accept it. She has o accept the reality that Khushi is in his life, and Shyam is out of hers.
Swapnali, welcome to the blog :)))
Balancing Relationships
ReplyDeleteIt is important to keep sight of it all. In a rush to ease one person's pain, forgetting another could be disastrous for all concerned.
Is you have seem "Bhool Bhulaiya" teh basic premise is sometimes incidents affect us but we bury them within us so deeply that at times they emerge again during times of upheavel and then manifest in weird ways - ways which may not be our normal response to things.
Ur post Sandy, reminded me of one of Tennyson's poem that i read in school....."The princess : Home they brought her warrior dead"
DeleteHome they brought her warrior dead:
She nor swoon'd nor utter'd cry:
All her maidens, watching, said,
"She must weep or she will die."
Then they praised him, soft and low,
Call'd him worthy to be loved,
Truest friend and noblest foe;
Yet she neither spoke nor moved.
Stole a maiden from her place,
Lightly to the warrior stepped,
Took the face-cloth from the face;
Yet she neither moved nor wept.
Rose a nurse of ninety years,
Set his child upon her knee—
Like summer tempest came her tears—
"Sweet my child, I live for thee."
The only tragedy is that the relationship Ani grieves for is for a scumbag....but yes, an outpouring of that grief is necessary. however she seems to be grieving for the loss of relationship status with her brother....
DeleteSandy,interesting post....stopped to think..my two cents below
ReplyDeleteThe dividing line between empathy and pity is very thin...
What is seen as empathy by me can be seen as pity by the opposite person or vice versa.....
what i am saying is while we spare thots for the ones who are going thru a tuf time, one cannot ignore to applaud the spirit of the ones who are making an effort to move on.Its injustice to both,almost in equal measure.
coming back to IPK, its a story and only the makers know how they want to represent their vision.
However, as a viewer the thing that disappoints me is if in the pursuit of making the main leads heroic, they dilute the essence of their love story, to the extent of making them give sacrifices that defy logic.
They end up making Khushi all sacrificing, Arnav all helpless while Anji-Shyam rule the roost.....Am not saying that Anji does not deserve sympathy...on the contrary, i would be happy if they show A_K helping Anji on the road to recovery...to help her see relationships for what they are....liberating even in their deepest bonds.
In this case, it is the nature of unnatural expectations, that is the cause for misery.The myopia in perspective strikes me that while Anji reserves a special place for her husband, she is unable to comprehend that her brother is also a husband to a woman who may demand the same position in his life. while I agree, its her past experience and her personal situation that is causing this myopia, i only hope they will look to correct her impression rather than pander to it....
You know I can somehow relate to todays epi specially the part where anji didn't knock.
ReplyDeleteJust a little bit of secret on my part, my hubby is an only child who apparently raised by a single mom. So basically they have each others back since time immemorial. When we're still dating her mom is fine to that but after awhile and finally we're getting married, and then got married that's when the situation changes for all specially for me. Suddenlly she became rude, she would barge into our room without knocking, opening our closet without asking and so many things that I couldn't bear.
Until I left with my two boys with me. To make the sad story short her son followed us. She was left behind. I feel sorry for her because just like anji she doesn't want to open her eyes, to see what's infront of her. But during my stay she made a point that I was just an outsider and it creeps me out recalling what she does.
Sigh totally unrelated to ipk but somehow I have to let this out sorry.
Cheng,
DeleteSo your experience explains Anji so well!
Glad for you things worked out in your favour.
Cheng,
DeleteI know of another lady, who was married to an only son ... his mother was so possessive that she used to come and sleep with them on their bed :(((
And so many inlaw stories, with possessive MILs ... the upshot often is what you experienced ... when the wives get fed up, they move out ... or else the husbands get fed up of doing the balancing act and move out with their wives. In either case, most often it's the over-possessive MIL who suffers, but they discover that too late.
My own MIL was similar ... very possessive about my husband, who is the youngest son after a long gap, so he was with my inlaws till we got married. Within a year we moved out to a different city ... he changed jobs because he got fed up of the constant tug of war between wife and mother. I wasn't SP bahu type either - I wasn't ready to let my MIL dictate to my husband ... ;)
So I can relate to Khushi too, because a new wife IS insecure as well ... Khushi is doing her duty towards Anjali, she's being understanding towards Anjali re the roses ... but she does want to know her own status in Arnav's eyes ... especially as the idiot just brought up the contract marriage after all they have been through together.
Rekha,
BINGO .... EXPECTATIONS ... my mom and I often discuss this ... where there are no expectations, things are easier ... One does tend to take certain relationships for granted, like parents, siblings, you know and expect they will be there if you really need them, but by and large, you get on with your lives, and they get on with theirs ... and in times of crisis you're always there for each other ... but you also have a life of your own, and both parties appreciate that.
Here Anjali has these unrealistic expectations from Arnav ... her duniya is him, and his duniya is her ... it was all well when she had Shyam and Arnav, now she has only Arnav, and she expects that his entire focus should be on her , the guy is not even supposed to have a quiet celebration with his wife in private.
Well, he, or rather his wife, didn't want to make it a big affair, understandably so ... but you resent even that he spend that little time in private with her ... that's a bit dog-in-the-mangerish.
Again, it's all about balance ... and it takes time for the old relationships to re-set themselves in the wake of new ones coming in ...
Ok as stories are shared ... let share one (this is a good excuse for me :D)
DeleteI was in my university second year when one of our batch-mate got married .... what excitement we had as she was the first.
She came back after a semester break ... we all wanted to know romantic moments and more of course. On top of her list was .... Her MIL crying for 2 whole days because her eldest son got rose bouquet for dear wife only.
(really wanted to share this on ME phir socha chalo chodo)
God we laughed are heart out even she did because neither we nor her was able to understand what it was indicating of future.
Ok I am liking GH more and more:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3096794
All rain talk at star plus is about the last year sequence:
http://starplus.startv.in/gallery.aspx?sid=124&aid=9291
Good one!
DeleteSandy – loved your post – I so agree – healing takes a lot of time and is a long journey. Self pity is also one of its stops, albeit the dangerous one as it can grow on you and totally suck you in. So anji going I have suffered so much will continue for a bit.
ReplyDeleteLadies - I am a bit confused:
I can understand Anji getting angry at her brother – it’s a very common feature to protect the person you love the most and blame others on minor things instead to taking the bulls by the horn and calling the creep the creep – I remember being angry at my mil for siding with her son but not angry at him for being a jerk! (I mean I was hurt but not angry for a while – until I snapped out of it and said – hey what the hell am I doing!) – So I can understand Anji feeling let down by her bro and can understand her avoiding the big issue by hiding behind the ‘how could chotey forget’
Now – Dia’s point is that she will always hold her brother closer than her husband – then in that case – she should not be angry at her brother at all, rather she should be supporting him. – what am I missing here
One point though – I have a grudge against the CVs – they really can’t develop the story, I mean the characters of the story to handle two situations – all have such ‘one track minds’ – be it Akash or ODB – which is not part of his character sketch – ok so his wife is imp – good (with a capital G) but why is he then not checking in on his sister at all?? What I really liked about ODB is his ability to think for all his family – he, despite not believing in love went all out to help Akash and sorted that out, despite problems with nani handled situations, despite fighting tooth and nail with ODG – never let anyone else harm or hurt her! Now CV have to be careful of how he goes about winning his wife back without hurting anyone – one good beginning - he organized a private thing for his wife not a big party.
SN – it’s a small thing but I can’t seem to get over it – why in God’s name do the Raizada women travel by autos??? These women are rich, or at least their husbands are – why can’t the husbands provide a chauffeur driven car for them to travel?? I understood that during the KN scenes mami and KKG had to go incognito – so fine but generally – why not cars or taxis? – These little things add to the story being well told (our CV should see some of the Pakistani plays – those are really good)
Mona about ODB not looking out for his sister bit ... well he is. First thing he did was explain his Di what he did, she wanted to be alone and he was asked to leave, still the very thing he did after he ensured khushi slept was to go look out for Di ... next day he went to office early morning, came back and found Di missing ... then spend the entire day with Di ... snapped at Biwi only to find her leaving ... now when he went out to GH he was expecting to force Khushi back ... instead he finds out its her BDay ... so did something he could to make up to her ... inbetween Di got the flowers ... he let her have it and also accompanied her to her room
Deleteand also the very thing he did while in office was fix Dis appointment and also requested Akash to take her as Di won't agree to go with him.
In a span of 2.5 days what else can be shown???
Mona, the whole point is that Anjali IS closer to her brother than to her own husband ... and so she EXPECTS that he will also place her above his wife on his priority list.
DeleteWhich in effect for Anjali now, means that the guy is not supposed to have a life of his own ... if Anjali is upset and crying 24/7, Arnav should also be upset and angry 24/7 ... definitely not romancing his wife, or celebrating her birthday. In other words, the entire house is in mourning for the death of her marriage ... how can there be any celebrations for whatever reason? Especially Arnav - how can he celebrate anything at all?
Dia....exacty thats the whole point....
DeleteIf they take this further to point that Anji is damaged...i can well understand this portrayal.
To turn it all, and say that it is only a phase in the life of a person who has seen calamity or is facing calamity all over again...I can't comprehend that...esp when she is not reacting to the actual problem at hand
This obsession is unhealthy...whichever way u look at it....
To accept someone as ur brother's wife only as long as bro keeps u first on list is not a sensible way to look at relationships....irrespective of whatever closures u achieve in ur life for problems. The premise is wrong to begin with...I can empathise but i can't accept...(looks contrary as a position but its not). I am one who also sees Khushi responsible for the situation she is in....her selfless acts notwithstanding.
someone has forgotten to tell anji in her growing up years that bonds of love are not measured by priority lists....
last point for today :D:D
ReplyDeleteThe Brother-Sister relationship – it’s interesting how the relationship has been shown – one has always held the other. When ODB was a baby, his sister was the mother figure (you said your first words to me) and even after the mother dies – Anji cont to be the mother figure. During crisis ODB became the savior last time – and I think she wants that again now. I don’t know if I am confusing you all – but what I am trying to say is that their relationship has always had one person being stronger than the other – not as equals, not as friends – and that’s where ODB&G are different - they are equals they can share, be in it together rather than one being the savior and the other the receiver. That’s what Anji needs to realize and ASAP!
'ODB&G are different - they are equals':
DeleteGood point, Mona.
Only, I am not sure if Anjali ever mothered him actually. She seems to have been the baby all through.
What I meant is, she fussed over him for sure, but I doubt if she was ever strong enough to be a mother in the nurturing sense.
DeleteSu, that is what I have always maintained ... Anjali was never the mother figure in their relationship. She was the child ... and Arnav had to grow up and become all hard and angry because he had to face the world for her, and fight her battles.
DeleteIf you look at all the Anjali-Arnav scenes, there are very few where Anjali has been the stronger figure ... when they both talk about their parents, Anjali always breaks down and cries ...
I remember this from the ma ka kangan scene particularly ... thinking that Anjali is worsening the situation for Arnav ... he had to run away and hide from Anjali ... see the difference in the way Anjali speaks to him, and the way Khushi speaks to him. Khushi is far more the older nurturing one here, giving him strength and faith ... Anjali has never done that, except in that one scene where she told him to go propose to Khushi!
Even when she talks about her death and Arnav doesn't like it, she never tells him, don't worry, I'll be around to bug you all your life ... she's just happy, see, my brother hates me talking about this, because he can't live without me. More to reassure herself about her importance in his life, than to reassure him ...
Dia - loved your edit -
ReplyDeletedon't give me the knife or else! - my favorite scene too
and her saying i will do all this on your borthday - same pinch - my first reaction too was - ok so you will be around :D:D:D
Love your edit as usual Dia
ReplyDelete"So she waits expectantly ... and he hesitates ... nope, no clue what to do next ...
The bag is a great excuse ... something he can scold her for ... now that he knows how to do ... "
This is exactly what set the tone of the epi for me :D
I have been think of this for last two days.. I love to connect and understand and empathise with characters, try to understand and reason why they did or say certain thing and justify it but somehow I am un able empathise with Anji today..
ReplyDeleteI can understand her mental state, her thinking and reasoning, her need for her brother at her crisis, the belief still in her husband almost like giving a second chance same as Arhi have given, The blaming of Khushi as root cause and everything else ... but still can't connect to her ... I can be sympathetic but can't identify with her as I do with most of the characters i love..
Why because she was always a weak character who wants everything as she wants- happy and gay at all times, or a person who wants to be centre of attention? Is it a disillusioned women who had so much of clues to ignore, or a women who was not even thinking twice to kill her baby, because she feels the baby might alienate her from the brother and the rest of the family.? Or because a woman who refuse to see the reality ?? I don’t know which is the reason but some how much ever I try can’t connect or empathize??
Yesterday, My father wanted to know my why i am fascinated with the serial...he realises this is an strange phase in his daughter's life and i guess like any well-meaning parent just asked me...whats the high point in this fictional drama that has caught my fancy....
DeleteWell, to cut a long story short, i tried my best to describe the story without adding any perspectives that i have formed(its extremely diffi to keep it on even keel) in abt half hour thereabouts...(that was tuf too)
At the end, my father said it is an interesting tale...still can't completely comprehend my attachment but this is what he had to say....basically 3 things
In the context of the story,
1) He said that "unless one has the complete picture of an issue/problem, difficult to say that one has made the best judgement/drawn best conclusion"
I see his words in this way..
Arnav does not know the part he played in bringing emo havoc in her life
Anji does not know the travails undertaken by Khushi to keep her world alive
Khushi does not know Arnav's past to have a complete understanding of what makes Arnav bitter about his past....
Payal (becos she is a character close to my heart!) does not know the predicament faced by Khushi during her marriage
Akash does not know the part played by Arnav during Payal's earlier marriage or his marriage
AND so on......
2) The second ting he said "as you make your bed, so u have to lie on it"
The way i see it:
Khushi chose to keep truth of Shyam from the RM family
Payal chose to keep the truth of Shyam from her husband
Arnav chose to keep the truth from Anjali about her husband
the RM family incl Arnav chooses to keep Anji in cotton-wool
The GH family kept the secret from the RM family to which they were bound by marriage
Anji chooses to stay in a make-believe world becos it suits her
And so on........
3) The third thing he said "many people overcome their grief when they are able to see that other's grief is the same if not greater than their own"
Rekhs, loved the 3 points especially the last one.
DeleteShweths, actually my father quoted "kurai ondrum illai" tamil composition of C.Rajaji to explain the third point...since it was a bit on the philosophical side, i did not elaborate (as it is mujhe verbal diarrhoea ki bimari hain...LOL)
DeleteHe said while one can choose to ask questions of Almighty of why a different fate for oneself,but it is also possible to see it as a situation of accepting and moving on by reposing faith in the very lord whose "diktat" one endures...Its tuf no doubt, but one must take courage to move on....
He said, this is true for both the theist and the athiest...A Theist will find it easy to accept that God is with him all the way while an atheist who has no expectation can take it as a set of co-incidences in his life and can labour on....
Sorry thoda zyada ho gaya.....
Rekha, NICE!
DeleteAnd so true.
Well the most important point, when my father asked me about why this fascination with this tale....after all our discussions...I sheepishly told him....."its actually the love story between the leads"....well....he just rolled his eyes...
DeleteI tell u....people...Who says the whole world loves a lover...blah....
Now, that was a bit of an anti- climax! *rofl*
Delete"I sheepishly told him....."its actually the love story between the leads"....well....he just rolled his eyes..."
DeleteSo true Su I was reading reading and then went eeehh ..... ROFL
Sama, Su....i have said this often enuf in R&R, the thing that keeps me rooted, hooked, booked to IPK is ARHI..story becos after a long time, i see in ARHI the quintessence of a love story...it has the makings of an epic love story....(minus the caricaturish turns at some points), the didi ki saut adds the volume but to me its not the entire tadka becos their love has developed despite its presence....
DeleteI don't care for love stories where one can't remember why people came together or why they went apart.For me ARHI is larger than life for both things..I will never forget why they came together or stayed apart.
I know TRP concerns will not let this tale be told in the original manner envisaged...inspite of that, its gripping....
Unfortunately, i couldn't explain that to my father...we are pretty frank abt a lot of things but phir bhi....yeh explain nahin kar payi.....LOL
Rekha...nice points by your dad!! :) I actually LOVED the very first one...it is very, very true.. :)
DeleteRekha,
DeleteI am with you thoroughly on this.
I started watching it as just another love story.
But when people call it a M&B now, I want to scream and tell them, "No. It is not. It is a CLASSIC love story."
The narration may get a little dragged here and there, but when the CVs get it right, they more than make up for those TRP-inspired letdowns.
I guess since I made that 'samjhauta', the magic will never wane. Even the OTT and kidnap had me hooked on, may be because I have this trust in the creative team now.
The GH tweets just re-affirm that faith.
Su,
DeleteI want to say this when i saw a 2-sec promo ads on screen.....that lamp and wick couple romancing in s'pore.....
Our ODB-G don't need any fancy locales or any setting...the poolside is enuf...to burn our screen....turn it on guys..waiting to exhale....
Watch the Birthday celebration here uncut:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTPX6Ctatio
Have to say finally Barun got Sukhi out of his system and ASR is backkkkkkkkk:)
Yeah, Shwetha, ASR is back!
DeleteDIa loved the edit. And Arnav just grins slightly ... vintage Khushi! Besides, she just said she'd be very much there for his birthday ...
ReplyDeleteMy fav moment of the whole episode.
ASR:
ReplyDeletePuzzled that Khushi could not appreciate his efforts to make her B’day memorable. The two fbs he had- the bag incident and her ‘roses made di happy’ talk with NK- hopefully he knows the way forward now.What matters to her is the thought and only the thought. What she wanted was only a simple wish from him. I really hope he can manage it at least when he gives that single rose.
Khushi:
It is not that she has not noticed his efforts. She appreciates the thought behind his actions. May be if he had not irked her about the bag being washed she may even have accepted his way of celebrating her birthday. That ‘laad guvnor' act got on her nerves, because it reminded her of the other LG act that had put her off in the morning. Couldn’t he make it special for her by just making her that special person who will get wished by him? The first time ASR opened his mouth and said HA.. she had even acknowledged his wish and said ‘dhanyawaad’. What made him explain it as ‘Happy Singh’? Was it because he wanted to wish her properly? OR was it because his big Laad Guvner ego wouldn’t let him? Is it because he couldn’t let her know that she had succeeded in bringing about this change in him?
I think this is why Khushi was upset. He was trying to do things ‘his’ way (1. Bringing up the contract. 2. Getting her the bag. 3. Refusing to wish her 4. Forcing her to cut the cake.) in stead of letting go of his ego and allow his heart to guide him.
Poor Guy! He was left wondering, “I did all this for you. Why aren’t you happy?”.
Anjeeee….
Your behaviour is acceptable for a woman in your state. Those red roses- they were not just a symbol of your brother’s love for you, but also the blood of your’s SIL’s sacrifice for you from the day she met evilwa.
When will you realize the magnitude of what she has suffered for both of you siblings?
lovely update Dia....lots of things put in perspective....
ReplyDeleteAfter reading the GH tweet and the posts, i could only think of one song that aptly describes the state of affairs....altho i love this melody, it is a quaint romantic number almost anti-romantic in its veneer...
ReplyDeletechhod de sari duniya kisi ke liye
yeh munaasib nahin aadmi ke liye
pyaar se bhi zaroori kayi kaam hain
pyaar sab kuchh nahin zindagi ke liye
chhod de sari duniya kisi ke liye
tann se tann ka milan ho na paaya to kya
mann se mann ka milan koi kam to nahin
khushboo aati rahe door hi se sahi
saamne ho chaman koi kam to nahin
chand milta nahin sabko sansaar mein
hai diya hi bahut roshni ke liye
chhod de sari duniya kisi ke liye
kitni hasrat se takti hain kaliyan tumhe
kyun bahaaron ko phir se bulaate nahin
ek duniya ujad hi gayi hai to kya
doosra tum jahan kyun basaate nahin
dil ne chaahe bhi to saath sansaar ke
chalna padta hai sab ki khushi ke liye
chhod de sari duniya kisi ke liye
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y2xMh4nsWkc from the movie "sarawatichandra"
someone should tweet this to GH .... guy will be flattered, the mere fact of a song dedication :D :D
DeleteSama...LOL.....actually we used to sing this song to tease self-absorbed lovebirds in our group....hehehe....
Deleteby telling them pyaar se bhi zaroori kahin kaam hain....get back...
no telling how words can be twisted....
Is this the same saree she wore in SPA promotion ???
ReplyDeletehttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDpyERhz_dE
No Sama its not. Guarantee none of the SPA promotion or outfits were used again they're owned by the PH that did SPA.
DeleteThe saree looks nice on fist view....OH what a waste, its thrown by the wayside....
Deletepehle toh acche kapde nahin pehenthe aur phir acche kapdo ab milta hain toh phekthe hain.....ohhhh!!
@Rekha.. haha! If you listen to the interview, Sanaya is quite upset that she had to throw away that saree.. :P even Barun says that Sanaya ko pasand hain lekin Khushi ko nahi.. :P
DeleteJust felt like sharing one of my personal experiences here...with all this insecurity talks ...
ReplyDeleteMy fiance is actually one of my best friend's cousin brother and both of them have always been very very close as siblings.. and I have been close with my friend ever since we started living together in Germany...we shared the same room there, so everyday 24X7 we used to be together ... we had one life.. her cousin (my fiance) was in Germany too, but in a different city than ours..so he used to always pay us visits.. but at that time when we were not dating, it was for his sister.. and when we started dating, it was like suddenly he was doing everything for me..
and it was just the first month that we had started dating...and well, my best friend was very, very, very insecure.. because hs efelt as though she had lost both her brother and her best friend (that is me).. it was very difficult to manage her at that time...especially since our relationship was new to us as well..but well, thankfully we had an amazing understanding b/w us, so there were never probs b/w us...but it took a long, long time for her to get used to the reality..to add to it, her own relationship had failed her in that phase..she had a not very cordial break up.. so it was like, she had lost her brother and me and her boyfriend.. it was difficult to manage her in that one phase.. :)
but now we are all out of it.. it took almost a yr for her to get used to the reality that I have now taken a very important place in her brother's life and that he in turn has taken an important place in mine.. :)
so I can understand anjali's state of mind ... but not exactly loving it.. :)
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3098264
ReplyDeletea absolutely hilarious post....
Early to bed and early to rise, keeps Khushi and Arnav celibate for life – Star Plus...ROFL Rekha...nice one!
Delete