20th Feb Mon
Heartwrenching, heartrending, heartbreaking ... Khushi, dammit, break your silence and tell them all - even I don't know why he's done this!!!
And it's a live-in disguised as marriage ... :(
Why did he leave her alone to face both families? x(
I actually don't blame her family for their reactions ... in their eyes she has shamed them completely, getting married like this in a runaway fashion, on the same day as her older sister's marriage, into the same family ... Nani getting worked up on Khushi was very annoying, though ... but again, same thing ... he left her to handle both families and she did ... and was totally broken by the end of it.
The small Shashi scene at the end was the saving grace - Shashi able to tell her that he believed in her ... Shashi probably would guess that Shyam is up to his tricks again, right now Shashi is the only person who has actually seen the ugliest face of Shyam.
He broke his word ... he asked her to marry him, not to live in ... but what he did was not a marriage ... sindoor and mangal sutra don't make up a marriage ... he has basically told her to live with him and pretend to be married for six months ... the saving grace is of course that he isn't planning an actual affair under the guise of marriage. And also that he gave her the cover of the symbols of marriage - a token respectability, as it were.But she is ruined nevertheless ... her family abandons her, her in-laws lose respect for her and the man she loves, hates her ... all to save her adopted sister's marriage the second time around ...
When is she going to ask him that all important question - WHY???!!!
Arnav, search your heart and ask yourself - was this really the only way out? Is this really only for your sister? Isn't it the love that turned suddenly and corrosively into hatred overnight when you felt she had let you down ... and isn't that the most unfair decision you have taken in your life? Marry her - yes ... but in this way?
I keep repeating a self-evident truth ... Sanaya Irani is simply heartbreakingly, breathstoppingly awesome in emotional scenes - I hate her for this!!! =D> =D> =D>
*edited ... more thoughts, am not doing a detailed update because there were not many subtleties today, just adding a few thoughts*
So Arnav does suddenly and belatedly start realizing the enormity of what he just did ... says, you wanted me to get married, so I did ... end of story.
But is it slowly starting to sink in that this is NOT the end of the story - the importance of marriage, the rituals, the sacred promises taken not just between two individuals, but in front of witnesses - marriage is a social contract ... All other relationships are from ties of blood, but marriage is the only relationship that is based only on trust, respect, mutual understanding and love - that is why they say marriages are made in heaven - by a higher power and with even greater sanctity than the blood ties that define all other relationships. Two people NOT related to each other by ties of blood, come together, promise to spend their lives together, make a brand new family, raise the next generation ... it is easy to stick to a brother or sister, even to mother and father, because those relationships are pre-defined by blood ties - but what makes two virtual strangers come together, promise to stay together and start a new family propagating new ties of blood ... only that sacred bond, with love, trust and understanding. A bond formed by God, and witnessed on earth by family, friends and society. Sindoor and mangalsutra, wedding bands, those are the mere symbols of that bond - they cannot be equated to the bond itself.
But Arnav chooses not to believe that - he does not believe that ... for him, marriage is a ritual, just a name, a face to show the world - so he gives Khushi that face ... but none of the emotions that define the ties.
So their bond was determined by Devi Maiya, and witnessed only by her too ... this time, not even the priest to do the honors.
Which reassured me - there WILL be a full ArHi marriage down the line - with full pomp, ceremony, all the rituals and all the emotions.
Nani blasts Arnav - good for her. Arnav is a bit abashed, but for him getting the better of Shyam is paramount. And Buaji starts off on Khushi ... okay, it was all justified, but painful to watch ... the only saving grace was that Shashi still seemed to understand that something big must have made her do this.
Anjali also questions - no answer. And he leaves - only stopping to give Shyam a victorious look.
Anjali and Arnav heartbroken on either side of the door - he says, "I'm sorry, Di," ... that's all very well, but have you given a thought to the girl whose life you just ruined? No, he hasn't - that half smile through his tears, because he's glad he destroyed her as well ... the girl who would have broken his sister's marriage or the girl who broke his heart?
Arnav is being painted VERY dark grey here ... a few thousand miles added onto that road to redemption ...
Nani now baulked of her prey, turns on Khushi ... rest was again painful as Nani, Anjali, Garima and Buaji all hound her ... Mami also gets into the act ... and Khushi can't say a word ... because what they're calling a marriage isn't even actually a marriage. Arnav tricked her, betrayed her .... told her to marry him, then gave her the symbols and the trappings of marriage and nothing else - to give her face in front of his family and the world ... but she knows in her heart that she and he are not married ... and yet will live together as man and wife ... a complete revulsion of all her principles and ideals.
And she can't say a word ... the sword of Payal's wedding will hang over her head always ...
Was Shyam angry because of her humiliation? Or because he realized that Arnav had won this round? The latter, I'm sure ... Shyam was equally willing to humiliate Khushi by implicating her in the necklace theft ..
The temple scene in Khushi's fb's ... again painful to watch as Khushi still begging Arnav silently to spare her, not do this ... tying the mangal sutra, putting sindoor, witnessed only by the havan fire and a silent Devi Maiya ... as though he's telling her, he's in charge of her destiny, not Devi Maiya ... but with Devi Maiya as her witness, she can't even repudiate their marriage.
"You believe in all this, don't you? Sindoor, mangal sutra ... here you are. We're married. But I will never acknowledge you my wife, never give you the respect of a wife. And six months later, I will set you free."
Destroy the girl. Who, just by being, just by existing, would have destroyed his sister's marriage. Through no fault of her own. She didn't ask Shyam to fall in love with her, to become psychopath in his pursuit, to attempt to kill not only his wife but her own father in that pursuit ...
Now it's a few LAKH more miles on that road ...
A repeat of the first Payal marriage break ... then too, Garima and Buaji were quick to break ties with Khushi ... has this happened with Khushi all her life ever since she was adopted? Every time there was a problem, was she always reminded of her adopted status? It happened during the forced engagement also ... Is that why she always tried her best to do everything she could for her family ... out of that ever-present fear that she never, ever truly belonged ... no matter how much she tried? Is that why she always hid her own tears, her pain ... and tried to be sunshine to them ... because they were never interested in her pain? Every time she went wrong, it was because she was not their own ... never because she was just a young girl making a mistake ...
Thank God for Shashi ... I think Buaji will be the first to soften ... she softened when she saw the father-daughter bond, and then fired again ... but there was genuine pain in her eyes as she saw the helplessly sobbing Khushi almost collapsing in her father's lap.
But it is always darkest before dawn ... Khushi is as down as she can be ... alone, completely alone, bereft of family, her supporters among her in-laws also lost, and the man she loves turned suddenly into a cruel unrecognizable stranger. She has nowhere to turn to except herself ... no one to rely on but her own strength ... and like a phoenix, she will rise again ... she has to.
Precap - if being married himself didn't stop Shyam, do you really think Khushi being married is going to stop him? Start using your brain, Arnav! Empty threats and picking on a defenceless girl are nowhere near enough to defeat the real enemy.
Abhas was found wanting today ... he didn't make an impressive villain.
Barun was okay ... hardly any screen space ... Arnav's unsympathetic character made it difficult for me to appreciate any acting. Although his smile through his tears in his room was strange ... we need an insight into his thoughts now, he hasn't conveyed them well enough.
Abha Parmar was good again ... Shashi was good, he conveyed his sympathy through his eyes. So did NK and Akash, they seem to be far less judgemental of Khushi than the older people ... I hope Akash is among the first to support Khushi, Nk is leaving and I feel really bad about that - Khushi needs all the friends she can get.
Sanaya was brilliant again ... I found myself urging her almost frantically ... talk!!! Say something!! Ask him why???!!! In the temple scene, she was simply brilliant as the dazed Khushi, the actual situation slowly sinking in, and her shame ... unable to say a word ... to anyone ... In the last scene as she runs after her parents and Buaji, frantically begging them to stay, not to disown her, to understand her ... to still love her ... because she has no one ...
Heartwrenching, heartrending, heartbreaking ... Khushi, dammit, break your silence and tell them all - even I don't know why he's done this!!!
And it's a live-in disguised as marriage ... :(
Why did he leave her alone to face both families? x(
I actually don't blame her family for their reactions ... in their eyes she has shamed them completely, getting married like this in a runaway fashion, on the same day as her older sister's marriage, into the same family ... Nani getting worked up on Khushi was very annoying, though ... but again, same thing ... he left her to handle both families and she did ... and was totally broken by the end of it.
The small Shashi scene at the end was the saving grace - Shashi able to tell her that he believed in her ... Shashi probably would guess that Shyam is up to his tricks again, right now Shashi is the only person who has actually seen the ugliest face of Shyam.
He broke his word ... he asked her to marry him, not to live in ... but what he did was not a marriage ... sindoor and mangal sutra don't make up a marriage ... he has basically told her to live with him and pretend to be married for six months ... the saving grace is of course that he isn't planning an actual affair under the guise of marriage. And also that he gave her the cover of the symbols of marriage - a token respectability, as it were.But she is ruined nevertheless ... her family abandons her, her in-laws lose respect for her and the man she loves, hates her ... all to save her adopted sister's marriage the second time around ...
When is she going to ask him that all important question - WHY???!!!
Arnav, search your heart and ask yourself - was this really the only way out? Is this really only for your sister? Isn't it the love that turned suddenly and corrosively into hatred overnight when you felt she had let you down ... and isn't that the most unfair decision you have taken in your life? Marry her - yes ... but in this way?
I keep repeating a self-evident truth ... Sanaya Irani is simply heartbreakingly, breathstoppingly awesome in emotional scenes - I hate her for this!!! =D> =D> =D>
*edited ... more thoughts, am not doing a detailed update because there were not many subtleties today, just adding a few thoughts*
So Arnav does suddenly and belatedly start realizing the enormity of what he just did ... says, you wanted me to get married, so I did ... end of story.
But is it slowly starting to sink in that this is NOT the end of the story - the importance of marriage, the rituals, the sacred promises taken not just between two individuals, but in front of witnesses - marriage is a social contract ... All other relationships are from ties of blood, but marriage is the only relationship that is based only on trust, respect, mutual understanding and love - that is why they say marriages are made in heaven - by a higher power and with even greater sanctity than the blood ties that define all other relationships. Two people NOT related to each other by ties of blood, come together, promise to spend their lives together, make a brand new family, raise the next generation ... it is easy to stick to a brother or sister, even to mother and father, because those relationships are pre-defined by blood ties - but what makes two virtual strangers come together, promise to stay together and start a new family propagating new ties of blood ... only that sacred bond, with love, trust and understanding. A bond formed by God, and witnessed on earth by family, friends and society. Sindoor and mangalsutra, wedding bands, those are the mere symbols of that bond - they cannot be equated to the bond itself.
But Arnav chooses not to believe that - he does not believe that ... for him, marriage is a ritual, just a name, a face to show the world - so he gives Khushi that face ... but none of the emotions that define the ties.
So their bond was determined by Devi Maiya, and witnessed only by her too ... this time, not even the priest to do the honors.
Which reassured me - there WILL be a full ArHi marriage down the line - with full pomp, ceremony, all the rituals and all the emotions.
Nani blasts Arnav - good for her. Arnav is a bit abashed, but for him getting the better of Shyam is paramount. And Buaji starts off on Khushi ... okay, it was all justified, but painful to watch ... the only saving grace was that Shashi still seemed to understand that something big must have made her do this.
Anjali also questions - no answer. And he leaves - only stopping to give Shyam a victorious look.
Anjali and Arnav heartbroken on either side of the door - he says, "I'm sorry, Di," ... that's all very well, but have you given a thought to the girl whose life you just ruined? No, he hasn't - that half smile through his tears, because he's glad he destroyed her as well ... the girl who would have broken his sister's marriage or the girl who broke his heart?
Arnav is being painted VERY dark grey here ... a few thousand miles added onto that road to redemption ...
Nani now baulked of her prey, turns on Khushi ... rest was again painful as Nani, Anjali, Garima and Buaji all hound her ... Mami also gets into the act ... and Khushi can't say a word ... because what they're calling a marriage isn't even actually a marriage. Arnav tricked her, betrayed her .... told her to marry him, then gave her the symbols and the trappings of marriage and nothing else - to give her face in front of his family and the world ... but she knows in her heart that she and he are not married ... and yet will live together as man and wife ... a complete revulsion of all her principles and ideals.
And she can't say a word ... the sword of Payal's wedding will hang over her head always ...
Was Shyam angry because of her humiliation? Or because he realized that Arnav had won this round? The latter, I'm sure ... Shyam was equally willing to humiliate Khushi by implicating her in the necklace theft ..
The temple scene in Khushi's fb's ... again painful to watch as Khushi still begging Arnav silently to spare her, not do this ... tying the mangal sutra, putting sindoor, witnessed only by the havan fire and a silent Devi Maiya ... as though he's telling her, he's in charge of her destiny, not Devi Maiya ... but with Devi Maiya as her witness, she can't even repudiate their marriage.
"You believe in all this, don't you? Sindoor, mangal sutra ... here you are. We're married. But I will never acknowledge you my wife, never give you the respect of a wife. And six months later, I will set you free."
Destroy the girl. Who, just by being, just by existing, would have destroyed his sister's marriage. Through no fault of her own. She didn't ask Shyam to fall in love with her, to become psychopath in his pursuit, to attempt to kill not only his wife but her own father in that pursuit ...
Now it's a few LAKH more miles on that road ...
A repeat of the first Payal marriage break ... then too, Garima and Buaji were quick to break ties with Khushi ... has this happened with Khushi all her life ever since she was adopted? Every time there was a problem, was she always reminded of her adopted status? It happened during the forced engagement also ... Is that why she always tried her best to do everything she could for her family ... out of that ever-present fear that she never, ever truly belonged ... no matter how much she tried? Is that why she always hid her own tears, her pain ... and tried to be sunshine to them ... because they were never interested in her pain? Every time she went wrong, it was because she was not their own ... never because she was just a young girl making a mistake ...
Thank God for Shashi ... I think Buaji will be the first to soften ... she softened when she saw the father-daughter bond, and then fired again ... but there was genuine pain in her eyes as she saw the helplessly sobbing Khushi almost collapsing in her father's lap.
But it is always darkest before dawn ... Khushi is as down as she can be ... alone, completely alone, bereft of family, her supporters among her in-laws also lost, and the man she loves turned suddenly into a cruel unrecognizable stranger. She has nowhere to turn to except herself ... no one to rely on but her own strength ... and like a phoenix, she will rise again ... she has to.
Precap - if being married himself didn't stop Shyam, do you really think Khushi being married is going to stop him? Start using your brain, Arnav! Empty threats and picking on a defenceless girl are nowhere near enough to defeat the real enemy.
Abhas was found wanting today ... he didn't make an impressive villain.
Barun was okay ... hardly any screen space ... Arnav's unsympathetic character made it difficult for me to appreciate any acting. Although his smile through his tears in his room was strange ... we need an insight into his thoughts now, he hasn't conveyed them well enough.
Abha Parmar was good again ... Shashi was good, he conveyed his sympathy through his eyes. So did NK and Akash, they seem to be far less judgemental of Khushi than the older people ... I hope Akash is among the first to support Khushi, Nk is leaving and I feel really bad about that - Khushi needs all the friends she can get.
Sanaya was brilliant again ... I found myself urging her almost frantically ... talk!!! Say something!! Ask him why???!!! In the temple scene, she was simply brilliant as the dazed Khushi, the actual situation slowly sinking in, and her shame ... unable to say a word ... to anyone ... In the last scene as she runs after her parents and Buaji, frantically begging them to stay, not to disown her, to understand her ... to still love her ... because she has no one ...