17th & 18th Aug episodes
Either the CV's are very confused or RP is a very bad actress. There are two possibilities right now - either this new girl is really old Nups and is pretending to have lost her memory, or she is old Nups who has really lost her memory. There is a third - that she is exactly who she says she is, but that seems to be a remote possibility as of now, according to all the articles.
So if the story is set, and it's only the trio who are confused, then RP is a bad actress. Because she is switching between the two possibilities randomly and neither is making any sense. Unless that is what the CV's want her to do, to maintain the suspense ... but there should be some consistency of characterization regardless.
Also, the trio's reactions don't make much sense. Okay, first reaction of Samrat was that she is play-acting ... but after that, why are they acting as though they are trying to catch her out? Especially in Wednesday's episode, Mayank? As though he and Nups are playing a game of one-upmanship ...
The photos scene was nice ... I liked seeing all the pictures ... but again, Mayank attitude was funny.
The Gunur last scene on Wednesday was good, actually Gunjan's dialogues were more consistent with her character today, and with her mindset - she is puzzling, but she is not accusing, she believes it is memory loss, so she is trying to revive some memories ... I liked her dialogues, esp when she says, let me feel, even if just for a few days, that my Di is back ... and it would be a stone hearted person who didn't melt to that so I was happy Nups agreed - for once, I even liked Rati in the last Gunur scene ... esp when she puts her hand on Gunjan's shoulder and Gunjan covers it with her own ...
Sam didn't do much today except back up Gunjan, again less accusatory today ...
Mayank was very confrontational ... so I found that part very inconsistent - does he think she's playing games and he has to catch her out? And WHY would they think she's playing games? For so long? Okay as a first reaction at the bus stop, tho' even that was silly ... for her too, it was three years since she met them ... but why would she carry on playing games? Very strange storyline ...
And again, she calls him 'sadu' ... so that is proof that she is Nups? Made me laugh ... is that all the proof Mayank can think of after being married to the woman, for heavens' sake?
RoAsh scene was okay, a copy of SG earlier scenes. Rohan is okay, as good or bad as Mohit was at that time, but Ash has to be much, much better to match up to Sanaya ... watching her, I realised how good Sanaya was in those scenes - with minimal dialogues, just with her expressions, her start when she sees Samrat, her changes of expression as he teases her ... Ash didn't impress. Especially as there is such a contrast with a far better actress.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Back!
Received a message about a spam comment, logged in to delete it, and browsed through the blog after AGES!!!! With work and home life gettin...
-
Monday 26th November '12 Episode discussions here please. All discussions on show ending in the previous post. Continuation of Frid...
-
Tuesday 22nd May First thoughts ;) - 87 comments before I wrote a single word - this has to be a record! Will need that second post toda...
-
(Piya Na Rahe Mann Basiya from Tanu Weds Manu) Hindi Piya na rahe man basiya (3 times) Sakhi re… English Translation [Love’s no lo...
No comments:
Post a Comment